This cottage (#2) was perfect for my fiance and I! The location is fantastic as we did not want to rent any vehicle and we could either walk right into the village (it's right around the bend from the main strip!), walk to 2 different beach access points, or hop a free trolley/shuttle anywhere we wanted to go! Which we loved to do! The property itself was cute, cozy, and had everything we needed for a 4 day stay. The rental office staff was warm, welcoming, very accommodating with holding our bags for us until our flights, letting us change our clothes both on arrival and departure, and supplying a new beach cart/wagon and cooler after I received an email prior to booking that stated these were provided. When we got to the cottage, there was no sign of these items and I contacted them right away. By the next day they delivered a brand new wagon and a cooler for us! It made the stay much easier and enjoyable!
Our ONLY complaint or issue was the bathroom. It desperately needs a full gut job and remodel. The shower stall is absolutely TINY, and I'm 5'2" and 120lbs, and I could barely turn around in it. Let alone my much larger fiance. And forget shaving anything in there! It was just claustrophobic and very uncomfortable.
However, that said, it was wonderful and if the bathroom gets fixed we can definitely see ourselves staying there again and again!