Our lower rating is a case of raised expectations. It’s obvious from the online reviews and the visitor book that many families absolutely adore this rental. One came back 15 years in a row! However, we were 3 older females visiting for the fall color and not swimming, skiing or sitting around the firepit. It has its good points but also disappointing ones. Good were the comfortable beds, 3 recently renovated bathrooms, heating control, excellent location on the awesome Ausable River, convenient for many local attractions. Good internet (but no cell service for AT&T). And it’s true that one person’s cozy may be dark and cramped to someone else. But although it’s lovely to hear the river, you can’t see it from the house and the path is treacherous for oldies, no railing. Road nose can be annoying at times. The kitchen is scantily equipped, the oven wouldn’t work. We missed the niceties you often find in rentals – a big pile of brochures and the owner’s detailed recommendations on all the local businesses, restaurants, a nice set of wine glasses, a decent tea kettle, instructions for the wood stove (smoky), etc. It’s the rustic Adirondacks and not Palm Springs, so if you keep your expectations in check, you might enjoy it more than we did. One note – we took 8 ticks off our little dog during the stay. This is not a criticism of this house, it’s a northern NY issue, but do be aware if you bring a pup.