Rocky Shore Escape: Neighborhood Beach, Pool Table, West Shore of Payette Lake

Thank you for sharing your feedback—we’re glad you found the home clean and as described. We’ll be sure to look into the items that need attention and hope to host you again. DoneRight Management | DoneRight Vacation Rentals McCall, Idaho

We’re so glad you enjoyed the home and location, and thank you for the helpful notes on the amenities—we’ll be sure to check on those. We appreciate your kind words about our team and would love to host you again! DoneRight Management | DoneRight Vacation Rentals McCall, Idaho

Thank you for your review! We're delighted to hear that you had a cozy and comfortable visit and that the house had everything you needed. We look forward to hosting you again in the future. If you ever have any specific requests or if there's anything more we can do to make your next stay even better, please feel free to let us know. DoneRight Management | DoneRight Vacation Rentals McCall, Idaho

Thank you! We're happy you had a great winter stay with plenty of fun for everyone—glad the kids enjoyed the pool table too! DoneRight Management | DoneRight Vacation Rentals McCall, Idaho

Thank you for your fantastic review! We're thrilled to hear that you had a great time and that you found the house comfortable and conveniently located. The fire pit and the peaceful surroundings certainly add to the charm. Should you choose to visit again, we'd be delighted to welcome you back. DoneRight Management | DoneRight Vacation Rentals McCall, Idaho

Thank you for the lovely review! We're so glad you had a great time, enjoyed the dock and neighborhood, and felt well cared for throughout your stay—we’d love to have you back! DoneRight Management | DoneRight Vacation Rentals McCall, Idaho

Thank you, Shannon, for taking the time to review this home. We appreciate our guests perspective and feedback. We are sorry that you thought this second-tier lake home was closer to the beach, but are glad that you got to enjoy it. Yes, the docks are private property and not to be used by our guests. We were happy to bring the wine bottle opener to the home for you, sorry that it wasn't there prior to your arrival, as it usually is. We are glad your family got to enjoy all the amenities that this home has to offer! We look forward to hosting you again, so please keep us in mind for your next trip to McCall, Donnelly, Tamarack Resort, or Cascade! -DoneRight Vacation Rentals, DoneRight Management McCall, ID

Thank you for taking the time to share your detailed feedback. I’m sorry to hear that your stay did not fully meet your expectations. While this home has historically received very positive reviews, we understand that it didn’t feel like the right fit for your group. The listing does note that the fourth bedroom is part of the game room, but I’ll be reviewing the photos and description again to ensure they accurately reflect the space and layout. Your notes about furniture, light bulbs, grill, and kitchen supplies have also been passed along to our team for follow-up. Regarding check-in, we always communicate that 4:00 PM is the designated check-in time, and our team does their best to accommodate early arrivals when possible. In this case, the home simply wasn’t ready earlier, and I regret that this overlapped with your meeting and caused additional stress. As part of our security protocol, housekeepers lock the door after preparing the home so that guests can use their unique code for entry. This helps prevent guests from accidentally entering the wrong property, which has happened in the past. We appreciate your perspective on value and comfort, and we’ll continue to use this feedback to improve. While I’m sorry this stay fell short, I do hope you’ll consider giving us another opportunity in the future with a home that better suits your needs.

Thank you Karen for the 5 star review! We are elated that you enjoyed your stay with us. Thank you for the feedback about the window coverings, we are looking at that as well, and have passed this on to the appropriate people. We look forward to hosting you again, so please keep us in mind for your next trip to McCall! -DoneRight Vacation Rentals, DoneRight Management, McCall, ID

Thank you Lori for the feedback! We are very sorry for the miscommunication!! We are so glad that you enjoyed your time and we very much appreciate your additional feedback!! These are important to our team :-) DoneRIght Management - DoneRight Vacation Rentals - McCall Idaho

Glad to hear you had an excellent stay. We hope to host you again in the future! -DoneRight Vacation Rentals, DoneRight Management, McCall, Idaho