I gave it 5 start because the questions asked deserved 5 stars. It was clean, the check-in was simple (emails before arrival told me what to do. No real "check-in" required, which was great). The staff I talked to on the phone were courteous and helpful.
The view was fantastic and was why I picked this particular unit. Sitting on the lanai for sunrise and in the evenings was wonderful. The beds were comfy and the AC mostly worked.
I liked having the bath sink separate from the toilet and shower. Free parking was key! FYI - We rented a Toyota 4-runner which DID fit in the garage, but just BARELY! I was pre-warned not to rent a full size SUV, but I forgot!
However, the unit's furnishings need attention. The bowls were mismatched and mostly chipped. There was no ice bucket to catch the ice from the ice maker, so I had to use a pot. There was no sink stopper to fill the sink for washing dishes, so I had to use a bowl. There were no coffee filters, and I didn't think to buy any during our one run to Safeway, so I used paper towels instead. The table is worn and wobbly, and there is barely enough room between the table and refrigerator. The bathroom towel rack is pulling off the wall.
Overall I'd probably look for different unit next time, but I would rent this one again if the price was right.