West Tisbury 1,910 rentals
    •  
      $811 avg/night
      5 Bedrooms, Sleeps 12
      4
    •  
      $308 avg/night
      3 Bedrooms, Sleeps 8
      5
    •  
      $323 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms, Sleeps 8
    •  
      $400 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms, Sleeps 8
    •  
      View listing for price
      4 Bedrooms, Sleeps 8
      5
    •  
      $521 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms, Sleeps 7
      2
    •  
      $400 avg/night
      3 Bedrooms, Sleeps 10
    •  
      View listing for price
      4 Bedrooms, Sleeps 9
      3
    •  
      $500 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms, Sleeps 10
    •  
      $371 avg/night
      3 Bedrooms, Sleeps 6
      3
    •  
      $357 avg/night
      3 Bedrooms, Sleeps 6
      1
    •  
      $2,143 avg/night
      7 Bedrooms, Sleeps 12
    •  
      $484 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms+, Sleeps 8
      19
    •  
      $491 avg/night
      3 Bedrooms, Sleeps 10
    •  
      $329 avg/night
      3 Bedrooms, Sleeps 6
      1
    •  
      View listing for price
      3 Bedrooms, Sleeps 6
      19
    •  
      View listing for price
      3 Bedrooms, Sleeps 6
      1
    •  
      $1,080 avg/night
      6 Bedrooms, Sleeps 20
    •  
      $927 avg/night
      7 Bedrooms, Sleeps 18
    •  
      $581 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms, Sleeps 8
      7
    •  
      $609 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms+, Sleeps 11
      9
    •  
      $600 avg/night
      5 Bedrooms+, Sleeps 10
      1
    •  
      $403 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms+, Sleeps 9
      9
    •  
      $286 avg/night
      5 Bedrooms+, Sleeps 12
    •  
      $750 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms, Sleeps 8
    •  
      $1,165 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms+, Sleeps 9
    •  
      $500 avg/night
      3 Bedrooms, Sleeps 6
      2
    •  
      $296 avg/night
      3 Bedrooms, Sleeps 8
    •  
      $239 avg/night
      3 Bedrooms+, Sleeps 8
      7
    •  
      $714 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms, Sleeps 8
      14
    •  
      $207 avg/night
      3 Bedrooms, Sleeps 8
      4
    •  
      View listing for price
      3 Bedrooms+, Sleeps 6
      2
    •  
      $357 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms+, Sleeps 8
      9
    •  
      $260 avg/night
      3 Bedrooms, Sleeps 6
      13
    •  
      $286 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms, Sleeps 8
      4
    •  
      $290 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms, Sleeps 9
      12
    •  
      $200 avg/night
      3 Bedrooms, Sleeps 6
    •  
      $243 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms, Sleeps 7
      7
    •  
      $143 avg/night
      5 Bedrooms+, Sleeps 12
    •  
      $284 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms+, Sleeps 10
    •  
      $643 avg/night
      5 Bedrooms+, Sleeps 10
    •  
      $286 avg/night
      3 Bedrooms, Sleeps 7
      3
    •  
      $230 avg/night
      3 Bedrooms+, Sleeps 6
      3
    •  
      $258 avg/night
      3 Bedrooms, Sleeps 8
      4
    •  
      $371 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms+, Sleeps 10
      3
    •  
      $714 avg/night
      5 Bedrooms, Sleeps 10
      5
    •  
      $328 avg/night
      4 Bedrooms, Sleeps 8
    •  
      $421 avg/night
      2 Bedrooms+, Sleeps 4
      4
    •  
      $720 avg/night
      5 Bedrooms, Sleeps 12
      1
    •  
      $171 avg/night
      3 Bedrooms, Sleeps 6
      4

Recent West Tisbury reviews

  • Relaxing Summer on the Vineyard!

    Heather

    "My family loves the Vineyard and we look forward to coming back every year. We've stayed at the Indian Hill house for the past six years and, it feels like home! The house has everything we need - nothing pretentious - just well appointed, casual and inviting. The kids (10 and 14) love to explore the property, visit the dog next door, and relax in the hammocks. We LOVE the semi-private beach! There have been times we've been the only ones there! It's a family competition each year who finds the most sea glass. When we do encounter people, they are warm and friendly. The location itself is perfect for us. West Tisbury is off the beaten path yet has so much to offer - MV Agricultural Society craft fair, annual fair, Cedar Tree Neck Sanctuary, Lambert's Cove, to name a few. Of course we make our trips into Edgartown, Vineyard Haven and Oak Bluffs for shopping, ice cream and fudge. But, we're just as content to hang at the house with a favorite book, play a family game, or relax on the beach. It's a great house to connect as a family. We're all looking forward to another lovely Vineyard summer."
    • Stayed July 2015
    • Submitted March 17, 2016
    • Source VRBO
    View this listing
  • Perfect Vineyard home

    Maura

    "We just returned from a week on the Vineyard. This was our second year in a row renting this home. The house is quaint and perfect for our family of 6 + a dog. We have 4 small kids and the house was perfect for us. The backyard allows for great outdoor fun with tons of yard to run freely and safely. The location is ideal and centrally located. Most importantly, the owner is available as needed, so welcome and easy going, but respects the privacy of a renting family. I would highly recommend this home for family's looking to enjoy the True experience of MV."
    • Stayed July 2016
    • Submitted July 19, 2016
    • Source VRBO
    View this listing
  • Excellent Rental - Clean, Ample Space, Quiet Location

    James M.

    "This home in West Tisbury is a hidden gem! Away from the crowds and chaos of other towns, we found privacy and serenity in this spacious, very clean and well-appointed home. Pam has anticipated the needs of her guests while also adding those little extras that contribute to one’s comfort. My family rented this home with our in-laws for an extended weekend in September to attend a family wedding. The house had plenty of room for us all the spread out and prepare for the events without getting in each other’s way (unlike a hotel) The roomy living and dining rooms were great for relaxing each evening. Pam’s yard is very generous and a very peaceful place to relax and “get away from it all”. We only wish we had had more time between planned events to enjoy all these accommodations offered. Pam was very professional, friendly and responsive - it was a pleasure working with her. We will certainly contact her first when returning to the island!"
    • Stayed September 2015
    • Submitted January 26, 2016
    • Source VRBO
    View this listing
  • Our Lovely Stay in West Tisbury

    Edward G.

    "This was our 2nd year renting the home and we enjoyed it even more than the first. The property is private and very quiet. It's conveniently located mid-island which affords easy access to bike trails to Edgartown and Oaks Bluff. The home has all amenities and Alice provided fresh eggs from the chickens in the back of the property. Property provides a step towards nature while providing all modern amenities. We hope to make renting this home an annual summer tradition visiting Martha's Vineyard."
    • Stayed August 2015
    • Submitted September 19, 2015
    • Source VRBO
    View this listing