This place has a fantastic location—close enough to walk to the town center, but it feels like a peaceful escape when you're at the house. The house is charmingly decorated in a rustic style and has all the amenities you might need. We especially enjoyed the nature around the house, with plenty of birds, rabbits, deer, and even fireflies.
The hosts are great—always responsive and friendly. However, it's worth noting that while Montauk generally stays cool year-round, the house doesn't have AC. If you happen to be there during a heat wave, it might be challenging for some people to stay cool and sleep comfortably at night.