Our stay exceeded all expectations. A friend and I came for a wedding and stayed just a weekend. The house is very charming, tucked away off the road in it's own private wooded enclave. The guest quarters is secluded, functional, and full of classic Hamptons charm and decor. With myself having the downstairs and my friend having his own bed upstairs in the loft. It was more than enough space for the two of us. The location is unbeatable too — convenient to both East Hampton and Sag Harbor, with the village, shopping, restaurants, and the beach all an easy reach. Not walkable, but less than a 5-10 minute drive from all attractions. What really made the stay though was the host, who went above and beyond at every turn. As newcomers to the area, we especially appreciated how they took the time to educate us about the area — sharing the best spots to eat, explore, and get our bearings, which made our time so much more enjoyable than most others in the wedding party. Check-in was seamless, the cottage was very clean, and every thoughtful detail showed how much care they put into the place. If you're considering this rental, don't overthink it, book it — five stars isn't enough.