Lejlighed·Privat vært

Perfekt --- placering, luksus, udsigt

Billedgalleri for Perfekt --- placering, luksus, udsigt

Et badeværelse med udsigt over en kystby, et vindue og en bordplade med en flaske og glas.
Et soveværelse med ovenlys, et stort spejl og en seng med blåt og hvidt sengetøj.
En moderne stue med et fladskærms-tv, et træskab og et spiseområde med bord og stole.
Et moderne køkken med lyse skabe, en sort bordplade og et vindue med udsigt til bygninger.
Et spiseområde med et rundt bord, stole og et morgenbord med frugt, en croissant og et glas appelsinjuice.

Anmeldelser

9,8 ud af 10.
Enestående

Højdepunkter

  • Skabt til afslapning
    Højt bedømt for komfort – gæsterne føler sig hjemme her.
  • Mulighed for parkering i parkeringskælder
    Nyd bekvemmeligheden ved en parkeringskælder – et sjældent fund i området.
  • Central beliggenhed
    Du er aldrig langt fra din destination med denne praktiske beliggenhed.
  • Oplev nærliggende seværdigheder
    Close to Chapelle de St-Pierre
1 soveværelse2 badeværelserPlads til 4 personer

Populære faciliteter

  • Aircondition
  • Kæledyrsvenligt
  • Køleskab
  • Tørretumbler
  • Mulighed for parkering i parkeringskælder
  • Internet

Udforsk området

Åbn kort
Villefranche-Sur-Mer, Provence-Alpes-Côte-D’Azur
  • Place, Chapelle de St-Pierre
    ‪2 min. gang‬
  • Place, Place de la Paix
    ‪2 min. gang‬
  • Place, Marinières Strand
    ‪6 min. gang‬
  • Airport, Nice (NCE-Côte d'Azur)
    ‪30 min. kørsel‬

Værelser og sovepladser

1 soveværelse (4 sovepladser)

Soveværelse 2

1 queensize-seng

2 badeværelser

Badeværelse 1

Badeværelse 2

Områder

Køkken
Spiseområde

Om overnatningsstedet

Perfekt --- placering, luksus, udsigt

Vi købte denne smukke lejlighed efter at have brugt fire år på leje i området. Villefranche er et unikt paradis på den franske riviera på grund af dens lille by, venlige atmosfære så tæt på den vidunderlige by Nice og tæt adgang til Monaco, Antibes og Cannes.

Vores beliggenhed er ideel og tilbyder spektakulær udsigt og usædvanlig stille i en efterspurgt gamle bydel. Institut de Francais ligger i gåafstand, ligesom stranden, alle butikker og restauranter, og meget let adgang til bil, bus og tog (kun en blok fra Place de la Paix,)

Lejligheden er blevet perfekt renoveret for at drage fordel af dets charmerende duplexlayout og tilbyder et soveværelse, spiseplads og stue med komfortabel sofa, to komplette bade, komplet køkken og en vaskemaskine / tørretumbler. Der er et stort fladskærms-tv med gratis adgang til franske kanaler, Dc-afspiller og telefon med gratis opkald i hele Europa og USA.



Nøgleord: Duplex

Tilføj datoer for priser

Lignende overnatningssteder

Marina
Vågn op til lyden af ​​bølgerne på stranden ...
Villefranche-Sur-Mer
  • Havudsigt
  • Køkken
  • Vaskemaskine
  • Tørretumbler
9.8 ud af 10, Enestående, (106 anmeldelser)
Vågn op til lyden af ​​bølgerne på stranden ...

Husregler

Indtjekning efter kl. 15.00
Udtjekning inden kl. 11.00
default

Børn

Børn i alderen 0-17 år er tilladt
default

Begivenheder

Arrangementer er ikke tilladt
default

Kæledyr

Kæledyr er tilladt
Small pets With prior approval
default

Rygning

Rygning er ikke tilladt

Vigtige oplysninger

Godt at vide

Overnatningsstedets registreringsnummer 61849276209FR
Overnatningsstedets nr.: 357381vb
Dette overnatningssted administreres af en privat vært (en person, der ikke udlejer som virksomhed eller erhverv). EUs forbrugerlov, herunder fortrydelsesret, gælder ikke for din reservation. Din reservation er dog dækket af din private værts afbestillingsregler.
Gebyrer for ekstra opredninger kan forekomme og varierer afhængigt af overnatningsstedets politik
Gyldigt billed-ID og kreditkort, debetkort eller kontant depositum kan være påkrævet ved indtjekning til dækning af påløbende udgifter
Særlige ønsker afhænger af tilgængelighed ved indtjekning og kan medføre ekstra gebyrer. Særlige ønsker kan ikke garanteres
Fester og events for grupper er strengt forbudt på stedet
Værten har angivet, at der er en kuliltealarm på overnatningsstedet
Værten har angivet, at der er en røgalarm på overnatningsstedet
Overnatningsstedets sikkerhedsforanstaltninger inkluderer brandslukker, førstehjælpskasse og lås med dødbolt

Om området

Villefranche-sur-Mer

Denne lejlighed befinder sig i centrum i Villefranche-sur-Mer. Nice Marina og Monaco Havn er begge oplevelser, som er et besøg værd. Er du derimod i shoppehumør, er både Promenade des Anglais og CAP 3000 Shopping Center oplagte steder at besøge. Ser du frem til et event eller en sportbegivenhed under din rejse? Se, hvad Circuit de Monaco eller Jean Bouin Sportspalads har på programmet. Udforsk områdets muligheder for oplevelser på, i og ved vandet såsom snorkling og parasailing i nærheden, eller nyd godt af den fri natur ved at kaste dig ud i mulighederne hvad angår cykling og vandre-/cykelruter.
Vis flere lejligheder i NiceÅbner i et nyt vindue
Kort
Villefranche-Sur-Mer, Provence-Alpes-Côte-D’Azur

Hvad ligger i nærheden?

  • Chapelle de St-Pierre - 2 min. gang - 0.2 km
  • Englenes Bugt - 2 min. gang - 0.2 km
  • Place de la Paix - 2 min. gang - 0.2 km
  • Museerne i Citadellet - 3 min. gang - 0.3 km
  • Marinières Strand - 6 min. gang - 0.6 km

Sådan kommer du rundt

  • Villefranche-sur-Mer Station - 7 min. gang
  • Garibaldi Sporvognsstation - 7 min. kørsel
  • Nice (NCE-Côte d'Azur) - 15 min. kørsel

Restauranter

  • ‪The Good Mood Café - ‬5 min. gang
  • ‪Espuma - ‬7 min. gang
  • ‪Plage Casa Soleia - ‬17 min. gang
  • ‪Alma Goût Méditerranée - Villefranche - ‬5 min. gang
  • ‪Spalato - ‬4 min. gang

Ofte stillede spørgsmål

Er Perfekt --- placering, luksus, udsigt et kæledyrsvenligt overnatningssted?

Ja, kæledyr er tilladt på dette overnatningssted. Visse begrænsninger kan gælde. Kontakt overnatningsstedet for at få flere oplysninger.

Hvor meget koster parkering hos Perfekt --- placering, luksus, udsigt?

Der er mulighed for parkering på overnatningsstedet.

Hvornår er indtjekning på Perfekt --- placering, luksus, udsigt?

Indtjekning starter kl. 15.00.

Hvornår er udtjekning på Perfekt --- placering, luksus, udsigt?

Udtjekning er kl. 11.00.

Hvor ligger Perfekt --- placering, luksus, udsigt?

Dette lejlighedskompleks ligger i Den Gamle By, kun få skridt fra Chapelle de St-Pierre og 4,1 km fra Promenade des Anglais. Derudover ligger Marinières Strand og Villa Nellcote ca. 2 km derfra. Du kan desuden gå til Villefranche-sur-Mer Station på 7 minutter og Beaulieu-sur-Mer Station på 29 minutter.

Anmeldelser

9,8

Enestående

Anmeldelser vises i kronologisk rækkefølge og har gennemgået en modificerings- og verificeringsproces, medmindre andet er angivet.
Få mere at videÅbner i et nyt vindue
Bedømmelse på 10 − Fremragende. 59 af i alt 67 anmeldelser
Bedømmelse på 8 − Udmærket. 8 af i alt 67 anmeldelser
Bedømmelse på 6 − Okay. 0 af i alt 67 anmeldelser
Bedømmelse på 4 − Dårligt. 0 af i alt 67 anmeldelser
Bedømmelse på 2 − Forfærdeligt. 0 af i alt 67 anmeldelser

10/10

Rengøring

10/10

Indtjekning

10/10

Kommunikation

10/10

Området

9,8/10

Annoncens rigtighed

Anmeldelser

Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Beautiful apartment and fantastic view. Lovely accommodation
Overnattede 4 nætter i september 2026
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Excellent stay
Overnattede 7 nætter i juli 2025
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
This place is clean, spacious, beautiful and in a great location. Russell, our host, was very helpful and kind. Excellent place and highly recommended. Thank you Russell!
Overnattede 13 nætter i juli 2025
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed

Fantastic Property

My partner and I stayed here for a week and truly didn’t want to leave. Perfect location to explore Côte d’Azur. Owner is was extremely helpful and assisted with recommendations, local amenities, and accessibility.
Overnattede 8 nætter i marts 2025
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed

Amazing view, great location, very comfortable apartment!

Russell’s apartment is perfectly situated in the old part of town yet close to bus stops that can take you to Nice, Monaco, Menton…It is a very nice apartment with modern conveniences, including AC.There is a steep stairway so I would not recommend it for those who have mobility challenges.
Overnattede 6 nætter i juni 2025
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed

Perfect 3 week stay

We had a terrific stay in this beautiful and well equipped flat. The location was amazing, the furnishings were tasteful and the home had everything we needed. The host was not only hospitable but went above and beyond to make sure we were comfortable. We can’t wait to return!
Overnattede 21 nætter i juli 2024
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Lovely Apartment!

Really enjoyed our stay in Villefranche! So relaxing & easy to go places on the train or bus. The apartment had everything we needed to be very comfortable!
Overnattede 12 nætter i oktober 2018
Svar fra VrboOwner den 25. mar. 2020
We're so happy you enjoyed your stay with us. We look forward to your return!
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Beautiful apartment at the very top of the old village. Lots of restaurants and shops nearby (some closed in the winter months). A 15 minute walk (uphill) to the Institut francais, so a nice little workout in the morning. I stayed for the month of February, and the town was quiet without many tourists. The weather was mostly nice and sunny with lows in the 40's F at night and up to 60F during the day. Be forewarned that the steps up to the apartment are steep, so a little difficult to maneuver with heavy luggage or if you are out of shape!Russell (host) is always available, as is his friendly father who lives in Villefranche-sur-mer.Lovely view of the harbor!Merci Russell and JP!
Living room
Kitchen
Loft bedroom
View
Overnattede 29 nætter i januar 2026
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

The Perfact Apartment in Villefranche-sur-Mer 🇫🇷🇫🇷🇫🇷

The apartment is perfect in the heart of Vieille Villefranche. It is modern and has everything that guests need! It’s very clean and comfortable near a boulangerie, a boucherie, a pharmacie and excellent restaurants. And the view of the sea is spectacular!
Overnattede 5 nætter i januar 2018
Svar fra VrboOwner den 25. mar. 2020
Thank you Schelly. We’re happy that you loved your visit to our home in Villefranche-sur-Mer. Melinda.
Fra arkiv

10/10 Fremragende

Perfectly located and absolutely lovely studio

It was an absolutely lovely studio. Not only was it well situated with a beautiful view, the apartment was perfectly well equipped with everything needed for our stay in Villefranche. It was very clean and beautifully furnished. Another positive aspect was how well the property manager communicated with us before and during our stay. I would definitely stay there again.
Overnattede 6 nætter i oktober 2017
Svar fra VrboOwner den 25. mar. 2020
We're very happy that you loved your stay at our apartment in Villefranche. Melinda
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Maureen & Rachael

We had a fantastic holiday in Villefranche, and the apartment was beautiful and very comfortable. It was an excellent base to explorte the Cote d'Azur. Monique was incredibly helpful and we were made to feel very welcome. We will definitely come back and stay when we return to this area. Many thanks for the use of your apartment.
Overnattede 14 nætter i juli 2018
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed

Stunning! Even better than expected!

The views are amazing from almost every window. The location is close to everything but not in the middle of the tourist area. The host is friendly and he and his dad gave us great tips for restaurants and hikes and made us feel so welcome. Yes, there are steps...but there are steps everywhere in town, so really not a big deal. Truly, I cannot say enough good things about this place! Thanks, Russell and Jean Paul. Look us up when you come to the US.
Overnattede 7 nætter i april 2025
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed

Villefranche-sur-Mer

Well-appointed little apartment in old part of town, perfect for a couple. Nice view of harbor, church bell/clock tower, and Cap Ferrat lighthouse in the distance. Easy access to bus, train, shops, restaurants, etc. Russell is a helpful and gracious host. Would rent again if we return to VSM. Lee and Jane
Overnattede 6 nætter i maj 2022
Svar fra VrboOwner den 19. jun. 2022
Thanks Lee for your nice comments! Would love to have you back! Hope alls well.
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed

Absolutely wonderful!

Can’t say enough good things about this place. Everything is just what you would want. The artwork is beautiful, the layout attractive and functional, the window view of the sea is perfect! And the stairs are doable. My husband and I, aged 68 and 71 handled that fine. We are in fairly good shape, but nothing extraordinary.
Overnattede 6 nætter i september 2019
Svar fra VrboOwner den 25. mar. 2020
We’re so happy that you enjoyed your stay at our apartment. We look forward to your return. Russell and Melinda
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed

Villefranche old town flat

Excellent location in quiet street with easy access for Uber drop off. Wonderful seaside view with two levels/bathrooms for privacy. Owner extremely helpful and on hand when we arrived/departed with restaurant advice, etc. Two flights of stairs to flat with another flight within flat, no lift. Area bus stop for Nice/Beaulieu 10’ walk. Interior recently renovated with modern WC’s. No question I would gladly stay here again.
Overnattede 20 nætter i september 2023
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed

Côte d’Azur Dream

Everything was promptly handled by the owner, Russell from the moment we booked. Russell met us at checkin and even carried our luggage up to the flat! He went above and beyond looking after us for the month we stayed with him. We cooked in the kitchen and many nights had charcuterie at the window overlooking the bay. Villefranche is a perfect location to travel into Italy or Cannes and Antibes for the day by train or bus. It was a dream place to stay. A big thanks to Jean Paul and his welcoming us to Saturday Boules with other English speakers. We would love to come back.
Overnattede 23 nætter i februar 2025
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed

Delightful apartment and excellent host

My husband and I really enjoyed our stay in this really well located and quiet apartment. Before, during and after our stay, I Russell was very helpful and informative. He met us at the apartment and walked us thru everything we could possibly need to know. We loved our happy hours, sitting at the big window in front of the dining table with a light breeze and beautiful view of the sea. We had no issue with the steep stairs but if you have mobility issues, this may not be a good place for you. Otherwise, we would highly recommend.
Overnattede 3 nætter i juni 2023
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
We loved staying in Villefranche , at Russell’s lovely apartment ! It was quiet, comfortable and had everything that we needed for 4 days. Russell communicated with me prior to the trip and after our arrival. We had the pleasure to meet Russell’s father, Jean Paul, who lives in the village. Jean Paul was sweet, friendly and so helpful ! Jean Paul recommended that we eat at Lou Bantry . It was our favorite restaurant in Villefranche. We went to Saint Paul de Vence one day on the train and bus. It is a gorgeous village. Get ready to walk a lot of steps in Villefranche:) Villefranche is close to many other beautiful places in the French Riviera that you can access by train for day trips ! Unfortunately the water was too cold to swim in for us in November. Hopefully we will be able to return some summer for another great vacation in Villefranche ! Merci beaucoup Russell and Jean Paul !
Overnattede 4 nætter i november 2025
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed

Perfect location with exceptional view

This apartment is convenient for exploring all the towns on the French Riviera by train or bus. The view is even more panoramic than the listing photo. The apartment has new top end appliances and a very comfortable bed. It is well equipped for cooking. We cooked most meals because the butcher store, market and bakery were so close. But we also ate out at several of the excellent local restaurants. The two bathrooms were a nice extra with bath fixtures in perfect condition. The location is quiet. We really enjoyed the easy access to the beach. Russell was very easy to reach to answer any questions and his father Jean-Paul was very helpful too. Villefranche-sur-mer is a hilly town so expect steep steps around town and getting into the apartment. We stayed for 18 nights in April 2025 and it felt like home.
Overnattede 18 nætter i april 2025
Fra arkiv

10/10 Fremragende

Lofty apartment in charming old Villefranche

This property has been renovated with the utmost care to use every little charming nook and cranny of the old walls for today's luxuries like washer/ dryer/ DW and great oven. My favorite place while home was to sit by the window in a tall chair to view over the rooftops the busy harbor activities of sailors anchoring their boats as well as cruise ships and ferries coming and going, letting off or collecting their passengers. Bring little binoculars! We liked the ease of wifi /phone / ipod player set up. It was wonderful to be right in the old town of stairs and steps, and expect the same with this apartment. The manager was very helpful bringing our suitcases up- and downstairs so this was not a problem for us older folks. Great variety of wonderful restaurants within 5 minutes of sauntering down some steps. Car not necessary since parking is difficult and great train or bus connections are cheap and easy to nearby Nice or Monaco etc.
Svar fra VrboOwner den 25. mar. 2020
Dear Maria, I'm so happy that you enjoyed your stay in our apartment while getting to know beautiful Villefranche. Sincerely, Melinda and Jean-Paul
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed

Perfect stay

Our stay in Russell’s apartment was for almost 3 months. First and foremost I have to say the hosts went way above and beyond. In addition to Russell, we were fortunate that his father happened to be in town during our stay and he went out of his way to not only make sure we were comfortable and set in the apartment but also brought us into the community. He toured us around the Cote d Azure and provided us with so much local knowledge. Both Russell and his father were incredibly responsive to anything we needed. As for the apartment itself, it was wonderful. The view across the bay every morning when I got up is an image permanently etched in my memories. The apartment is ideally located in Old Town with many nearby restaurants and a 10 minute picturesque stroll to the nicest beach in the region. Yes, there are stairs. But the entire region is hilly so if you aren’t comfortable negotiating uphill and downhill terrain, this region may not be right for you. We are in our 60’s and had no trouble with the stairs however we were sure glad to have help with our luggage on arrival. Overall, I cannot speak highly enough about what great hosts Russell and his father were and what a perfect location and apartment this is for a base camp to explore the Cote d Azur.
Overnattede 90 nætter i april 2024
Fra arkiv

8/10 Godt

Pretty apartment-Not a fit for all

Firstly, we are very well-travelled, late fifties, fit and have lived in three different countries. This apartment is very well located in the lovely town of Villefranche. You can walk to the wonderful restaurants, churches, beach and train station. The trains, were, however, on strike during our stay. The flat is very bright and well-furnished with dish-washer, washer, dryer and T.V. There are two bathrooms- a neccesity, because of the curved stairs. It was extremely clean and well- maintained. There are two caveats here. This apartment does not have air-conditioning, nor does it have an outside patio or balcony. As a result, it is very warm during the summer months. Villefranche is located on a hill and contains many steps. This apartment contains stairs as well, both from the sidewalk and within the apartment itself. It would not be appropriate for children, or people with any physical challenges. While the owner did contact us to ask for input, she was not helpful in offering a solution to our take on both the heat and the stairs. We ended up spending a night at a hotel with air-conditioning and a pool in order to cool off. If this is not an issue for you, then you may like this property.
Svar fra VrboOwner den 25. mar. 2020
We are happy that Nigel and Katherine liked our apartment, but sorry that their visit coincided with a heat wave and a train strike which they understandably found trying. Villefranche is a charming 13th C. village with many stairs leading to the sea in the pedestrian zone. Fortunately, we are located on an ideal street within the old town, just 100 yards and five steps down from the Place de la Paix which has taxi access, a bus stop and many small shops. The apartment is a duplex located on the second floor of our small building, accessible via a flight of stairs, steep by American standards (see photographs in listing.) Normally, our thick stone walls, large modern windows and excellent cross ventilation provide quiet, comfortable sleeping.
Verificeret anmeldelse

10/10 Fremragende

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Superbly appointed apartment, with gorgeous view of the bay. Well located and very well managed.Host is extremely helpful and prompt.
Overnattede 28 nætter i april 2026
Verificeret anmeldelse

8/10 Godt

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed

Nice stay

We enjoyed our stay in Villefranche. This was very centrally located. Beware that there are 24 very steep stairs to get into the property. One there, you have a beautiful view.
Overnattede 6 nætter i oktober 2022
Verificeret anmeldelse

8/10 Godt

Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed

Very good, but...

We are in our mid-sixties, and the apartment, while perfectly fine, was difficult for us to navigate. Stairs from the street to the apartment are steep and narrow. We could not have made it up or down with our luggage on our own. Russell helped when we arrived and we paid one of Russell's neighbors to help us when we left. Even without luggage the stairs were a chore. Once in the apartment there is another stairway to the bedroom; also not easy. Villefranche is lovely but vertical, and there are no lifts. There is one private beach club, which you need to book in advance. Les Garcons is a wonderful restaurant.
Overnattede 7 nætter i september 2022

Om værten

Vært: Russell Lecomte

Værtens profilbillede
Jean-Paul and Melinda Lecomte and son Russell. who live in Maine, Villefranche and Shanghai.

Derfor valgte værten dette overnatningssted

Jean-Paul grew up in nearby Antibes. We found Villefranche when Melinda attended the Institut Francias and fell in love with the small village and its proximity to Nice

Derfor er dette overnatningssted unikt

Villefranche is a 'little paradise.' We have the beach, great restaurants, and the most beautiful view on the Cote d'Azur. Our town still offers a small village ambiance just minutes away from bustling Nice, Antibes, Cannes and Monaco.

Sprog:

engelsk, fransk, spansk, Kinesisk (mandarin)

Premium-vært

Værten sørger gang på gang for, at gæster får en god oplevelse.
Fortæl os, hvordan vi kan forbedre vores hjemmesideGiv feedback