Sheridan House- The Suite apartment is a fantastic spot with a high city feel in a small town. Located in the historic Main Street business district in Penn Yan, this second floor walkup apartment has been completely renovated and has all the modern amenities while keeping that historic charm.
The street entry door opens to a flight of stairs shared by the Sheridan House Studio and the Sheridan House Suite. The Suite has an open living concept with the kitchen, dining, and living room space all open to each other, graced by high ceilings.
The kitchen is fully stocked with cookware, dinnerware for 4, and a coffee maker, and has a large Island with counter-height seating. The dining room table comfortably seats 4 if you'd like the pleasure of a sit-down meal. The sitting area has a comfortable couch, arm chairs and a dedicated desk area.
The large bedroom is connected to the main living area by a set of pocket doors that opens into the sitting area and boasts a beautiful king size canopy bed. Large floor to ceiling windows look out onto the back parking area and street, allowing lots of natural light to come in. The large bedroom has an attached full bath with beautiful white tile and a tub/shower.
The second bedroom is adjacent to the kitchen end of the apartment and has a comfortable queen size bed. The second full bath is just around the corner in the hallway, has a beautifully tiled tub/shower, and there is a large hall closet containing a full size washer and dryer.
The Suite is the perfect 'home away from home' apartment, whether you're traveling for work, or with a few friends. You'll love the coffee shop down the street, Amity Coffee Co, the Burnt Rose Wine Bar below (which often features live music in the evening) and you'll find restaurants and bars just across the street or within a block of the apartment as well as proximity to many of the wineries and breweries in the area. If you're looking for a modern, comfortable apartment to stay in during your time in Penn Yan, you are welcome at the Sheridan House Suite!
Originally constructed in 1880 by John Sheridan as the Sheridan House Hotel, this historic property has long welcomed guests from near and far to enjoy everything the Finger Lakes has to offer. The first floor below the apartment, which boasted an oyster bar in the late 19th century, today houses a locally owned and operated wine bar. Guests may be able to hear some muffled noise and music from the wine bar below the apartment. The wine bar is restricted from operating or making noise late at night, although they do have live music multiple evenings a week. Quiet hours begin for them at 10PM each night in order to minimize potential disruption to our guests.
EV charging is available at the town library- 2 blocks away and just a short 5 minute walk from the apartment.
*Air conditioning is provided via central air *A limited amount of paper towel, toilet paper, soaps, is provided for each guest.
**We ask that renters to be over the age of 25. By booking you agree with this policy and comply with the request that the renting party is over the age of 25. **No pets or animals allowed at any time. Anyone found to be in violation, will be asked to leave immediately and/or charged an additional fee **No parties allowed at any time. **Smoking prohibited **Parking is available in the public parking area behind the building **Guest must comply with maximum occupancy at all times. Only 4 guests allowed at any time, additional guests will be asked to leave **Guests are asked to initial a rental waiver, sent via email, immediately after booking. Permit #: 26-1012
Add dates for prices
Have a question?
AI iconBetaBeta
Get instant answers with AI powered search of property information and reviews.
Similar properties
Cozy, rustic cabin with beautiful views, privacy and 1 mile from Keuka Lake
PennYan
Cozy, rustic cabin with beautiful views, privacy and 1 mile from Keuka Lake
A dreamy Seneca Lake retreat with sweeping views, a relaxing hot tub under the stars, flexible bedroom setups, a fully stocked kitchen, cozy living spaces, and easy access to the lake, wineries, and waterfalls.
Romulus
A dreamy Seneca Lake retreat with sweeping views, a relaxing hot tub under the stars, flexible bedroom setups, a fully stocked kitchen, cozy living spaces, and easy access to the lake, wineries, and waterfalls.
You are welcome to the limited supply of disposable paper goods, shampoos, soaps, dishwashing detergent, etc.
Important information
You need to know
Extra-person charges may apply and vary depending on property policy
Government-issued photo identification and a credit card, debit card or cash deposit may be required at check-in for incidental charges
Special requests are subject to availability upon check-in and may incur additional charges; special requests cannot be guaranteed
On-site parties or group events are strictly prohibited
Host has indicated that there is a carbon monoxide detector on the property
Host has indicated that there is a smoke detector on the property
Safety features at this property include a fire extinguisher, a first aid kit and a deadlock
About the area
Penn Yan
Located in Penn Yan, this apartment is in a rural area. The area's natural beauty can be seen at Keuka Lake and Seneca Lake. Enjoy the area's slopes with snowboarding and skiing, and don't miss out on the ice skating and snowmobiling.
The Windmill Farm & Craft Market - 9 min drive - 12.0 km
Watkins Glen State Park - 37 min drive - 46.7 km
Restaurants
McDonald's - 12 min walk
Taco Bell - 9 min walk
Seneca Farms - 2 min drive
Sunoco - 3 min walk
Silverbird Woodfired - 2 min walk
Frequently asked questions
Is Sheridan House-The Suite-gorgeous downtown apt pet-friendly?
No, pets are not allowed at this property.
How much does it cost to stay at Sheridan House-The Suite-gorgeous downtown apt?
As of 8 May, 2026, prices found for a 1-night stay for 2 adults at Sheridan House-The Suite-gorgeous downtown apt on 10 May, 2026 start from S$449, including taxes and fees. This price is based on the lowest nightly price found in the last 24 hours for stays in the next 30 days. Prices are subject to change. Choose your dates for more accurate prices.
How much is parking at Sheridan House-The Suite-gorgeous downtown apt?
On-site parking is available at the property.
What time is check-in at Sheridan House-The Suite-gorgeous downtown apt?
Check-in begins at 4:00 PM.
What time is check-out at Sheridan House-The Suite-gorgeous downtown apt?
Checkout is at 10:00 AM.
Where is Sheridan House-The Suite-gorgeous downtown apt located?
Situated in a rural location, this apartment building is within 1 mi (2 km) of Arts Center of Yates County and Keuka Lake. Oliver House Museum and Keuka Lake Outlet Trail are also within 3 miles (5 km).
Reviews
10
Exceptional
Reviews are presented in chronological order, subject to a moderation process, and verified unless otherwise labelled.
We had a great time in this charming little town. The apartment was also full of charm and very clean. The Wagner Restaurant has the best breakfast with a small town diner feel - we ate their every morning for breakfast. We all loved everything about our stay and if we decide to go back we'll definitely stay at the Sheridan House again.
We couldn’t have been happier or more comfortable. The 2 bedroom, 2 bath accommodations were perfect for 4 adults. We were in love with the place from the moment we opened the door. Just beautiful! Loved the location, central to everything we needed from shopping the quaint little shops and fabulous restaurants. I wanted to live there!
Absolutely the most clean and well-kept rental we have ever stayed in. Zero dust anywhere!! Location was perfect. Check-In and Check-Out was easy. Will definitely be staying here again!!
Mike L.
Stayed 2 nights in Aug 2023
Verified
10/10 Excellent
Nancy
11 Jul, 2024
Liked: Cleanliness, amenities, property conditions & facilities, communication
Very clean, chic decor, quality EVERYTHING. Absolutely loved it.
We enjoyed our stay on a beautiful fall weekend. Loved the restaurants and breweries / vineyards. We wish we knew about the restaurants on Keuka Lake. We enjoyed our trip. Wish the girls had a little more shopping and wish the group had a few more towels. Ither then that we had a blast !!!
The Suite unit was clean, tastefully decorated, and had every amenity. Check in was a breeze. We loved the convenience to restaurants and everything was an easy drive. I’d stay again!
Gorgeous walk up. Beautifully appointed. Several great restaurants within walking distance. The listing is above a wine bar but noise from the restaurant was never an issue.
My husband and I stayed in the suite for 3 nights mid-week. It was awesome. Communication and ease of check-in was effortless. Everything was new and the decor was a beautiful mix of old charm with modern furnishings. Parking was plentiful and staying right in town was very convenient. The town itself was very quiet and there were several restaurants right outside your door. The Keuka Restaurant right across the street was excellent. We loved the location because you could easily travel to either side of the lake to visit wineries and breweries. We truly love the area and would definitely stay at the Sheridan House suite again!
This place is absolutely beautiful. Old building charm with all the modern amenities. Bed was very comfy. Cool vibe. All around great place - easy access to many wineries in the area. And there are restaurants on the same block. Off street parking behind bldg was a helpful.
The place was as pictured, which was very nice. The noise from the wine bar below wasn't bad and they closed up pretty early. The bedroom is overlooking a parking lot and there was some morning noise. Several nice restaurants within 20 feet of the apartment. Overall a great stay that we'd be happy to repeat.
The Suite was perfect for two couples visiting from out of town for a family wedding. Did our own breakfasts, were out and about wine tasting and lunching, and dinner in the immediate neighborhood. The Burnt Rose Wine Bar was excellent as was the sister establishment 18th Amendment for cocktails. Easy parking out front for unloading and out back.
Very nice unit/apartment located in downtown Penn Yan. Location was great for getting to many of the sites we wanted to see ie: canandaigua, Hammondsport, Watkins Glen etc. the place felt clean and cared for and updated. Kitchen was well stocked. A bit small for 4 adults but adequate. The “living area” not as comfortable seating as I would have liked, but wouldn’t take it off my list or high score. Our “master” room was great, the 2nd bedroom is extremely small, no closet, just an armoire, and would be great for kids but not another adult couple. The master has its own bathroom, the secondary bedroom had to use the hall bathroom which meant entering the kitchen/living area to get to it. Not ideal, you just need to know what you’re getting as we still liked the unit. Master bedroom bed was soooo comfy, good sleeping. Penn Yan has most everything you need, much within walking distance. Unfortunately we didn’t find restaurants that served the quality we wanted, but there’s plenty available.
We had a very pleasant stay in the Sheridan Suite. Perfect for our week away and so much better that a hotel room. Lots of space with a pleasing design and comfortable furnishings. Very well equipped with full size kitchen and laundry appliances and two full baths. Sheets and towels were good quality and a small shampoo and soap were provided. Both the king-size and queen-size beds had a Tempurpedic mattress topper on it, which took some getting used to. It proved to be pretty comfortable, but they definitely do hold your body heat. Full service grocery stores (Topps and Aldi) as well as drug stores within a two block walk. Easy to walk to everything downtown. Very convenient and free parking behind the building. Took advantage of the Amity Coffee Co. every morning that is on the first floor of the building. Best meal we ate was at the Union Block, only a block away. Only two very minor negatives. One was hiccup with the electronic lock coding when we arrived. We got through the street-level door but the code to the apartment itself had been entered with a typo. Only took about 5 minutes for the problem to be resolved after calling the emergency # on our reservation (we arrived after business hours). The second was that the tub liner shower curtain really needed a good scrubbing and bleaching as mold/mildew was evident in the hem. Otherwise, the apartment was very clean. We would definitely stay here again!
What a beautiful place! Perfect for our long weekend getaway. Our favorite places were Parker’s for food, the Christmas store and the little coffee shop. Parker’s had great food and we will definitely be eating there again!
The only recommendation I would have is to put a fan in the queen room. It got warm in there. Other than that, we loved it!!!
Nicole C.
Stayed 3 nights in Nov 2022
Response from VrboOwner on 9 Apr, 2023
We are glad to hear you enjoyed our small town, thanks for staying!
This was a very nice place to come back to after a day of touring the finger lakes. Super cute and as pictured. It’s above a nice wine bar with great food. Nearby are other really good restaurants, a great coffee shop, and an amazing bakery up the street.
It was a seamless process. The property is located in the perfect spot. Loved how convenient it was to hit up local restaurants.
Aimee S.
Stayed 2 nights in Oct 2022
Response from VrboOwner on 9 Apr, 2023
Glad to hear you enjoyed your stay!
About the host
Hosted by Joleen Glick
We are a husband/wife vacation rental management team and owners at Linger Hospitality. We, along with our co-host, Ruth, are excited for you to stay in our vacation home. We have lived in the heart of the Finger Lakes for many years and are in love with this beautiful region of NY. We love sharing the beauty of the lakes, woods and vineyards of the FLX with our guests and are excited for you to come and be our guest at one of our vacation rental homes. We can't wait for you to get the full FLX experience...enjoying the water on one of the lakes, sipping wines from the many fantastic wineries in the area, trying craft beers from the breweries, or sampling the amazing foods from the eateries. Come visit the Finger Lakes and be our guests!
Languages:
English
Premier Host
They consistently provide great experiences for their guests