NEW Beachfront & Gulf Water Views Loggerhead Cay 354— heated Pool, Tennis, Pickleball & Beach Gear. Weekly Stays

Welcome to the new Loggerhead Cay 354, a tropical retreat on beautiful Sanibel Island where lush vegetation, swaying palms, and clear blue Gulf waters create the feeling of a Caribbean getaway. It’s hard to believe you’re still in Florida.

Sanibel has been recognized as one of the Best Places to Visit in 2026 by Travel + Leisure and featured in The New York Times’ “52 Places to Go in 2026,” thanks to its natural beauty, peaceful atmosphere, and world-famous shelling beaches.

Caihlin is available as often as needed but also provides guests with plenty of space to enjoy a relaxing and tranquil vacation. As the owner of Coastal Joy Vacation Rentals since June 2018—and with over 8 years of experience hosting in Southwest Florida—she knows what it takes to deliver a seamless stay. With more than 300 five-star reviews across several channels, including Google, you can book with confidence knowing you're in excellent hands.

Sanibel Island is a tropical paradise known for its world-class shelling, pristine beaches, bike-friendly paths, and laid-back charm. With no high-rises and a strong commitment to preserving its natural beauty, Sanibel offers a peaceful, authentic escape.

The East End of the island holds special appeal. It’s the most convenient area for off-island access via the Sanibel Causeway, meaning less traffic and quicker trips to the mainland. The East End also features the historic Sanibel Lighthouse, fishing pier, scenic beaches, charming shops, and quiet residential streets.

Its location makes it perfect for those who want to explore the island by bike or on foot, enjoy less crowded beaches, and access the best of Sanibel and beyond with ease.

Did I mention shelling? Will you find the royal shell, Junonia, next time you visit?

Guest access:
You will have private access to the entire condo for the duration of your stay, including the oversized swimming pool, amazing community lounge spaces, tennis/pickleball courts and community outdoor spaces. Designated Free parking is available in the parking lot, there is additional Free guest parking too!

In addition, we feature high-end linens and amenities that elevate the travel experience for any discerning guest.

We have several other similar vacation rental properties on Captiva, Sanibel & Fort Myers Beach FL, so if your travels ever take you here please reach out. We would love to host you at any of our vacation rental properties!

The Space

Be among the first to experience Loggerhead Cay 354 with new introductory pricing while we finalize the listing. Interior photos are coming soon, but this beautifully remodeled and fully updated condo is ready to welcome guests now. Book early to enjoy Gulf water views and an ideal location within the community—just steps from the heated pool, pickleball and tennis courts, and convenient grilling areas.

This comfortable and stylish unit sleeps up to 6 guests and features a thoughtful layout perfect for families or small groups. The primary bedroom offers a king bed, while the guest bedroom includes two full beds and a twin-over-bunk, giving everyone space to relax. Also, when traveling with little ones, there is a Pack ' N Play in the unit. Enjoy built-in USB & USB-C adapters in furniture, plus the convenient charging station in the guest room!

The master & guest bathroom have ADA grab rails in the shower

The condo has been completely updated throughout, blending modern comfort with coastal charm. One of the highlights is the no-see-um screen enclosed lanai, perfect for enjoying morning coffee or relaxing dinners while taking in the tropical surroundings.

Whether you’re heading to the beach, grilling by the pool, or biking around the island, Loggerhead Cay 354 offers the perfect Sanibel Island retreat. You will not be disappointed. With the numerous additional Unit 354 amenities, such as CoolCabana Beach Tent, Pickleball Paddles and other items to make your stay more enjoyable!

Loggerhead Cay offers resort-style living just steps from the sand, with amenities including tennis and pickleball courts, a large heated pool, abundant grilling areas, and convenient shell-washing stations after a day on the beach.

Explore the island along miles of scenic bike paths, where you can spot native wildlife, tropical birds, and stunning coastal landscapes. Spend your days shelling, biking, relaxing by the pool, or enjoying sunset walks along the shoreline.

Whether you’re seeking adventure or pure relaxation, Loggerhead Cay 354 is the perfect place to experience the magic of Sanibel Island. Sanibel is very bike-friendly, with bike paths separate from the road throughout the island. Some of the best parts of Sanibel are best experienced at a slower pace, especially spotting wildlife while biking. Inquire with Caihlin about bike rentals!

The #1 reason to book at Loggerhead Cay is the new Rare Premium Amenity: No-See-Um & Mosquito Control System by Mosquito Masters!

Rental Dwelling License # LCB20261987

Loggerhead Cay 354 is located on Sanibel Island’s peaceful East End, where getting around is part of the fun. Most guests find that a car isn’t always necessary once they arrive — the island is compact, calm, and designed for biking and walking.

Rent Bikes, perfect for exploring Sanibel’s 25+ miles of scenic bike paths, local cafés, and the historic Sanibel Lighthouse, just a short ride away.

If you prefer to drive, free on-site parking is available, and most island attractions, shops, and restaurants are within a 5–10 minute drive.

Taxis and ride-share options are limited on the island, but local bike and car rental companies can deliver directly to the condo.

Caihlin, founder of Coastal Joy Vacation Rentals in Fort Myers, turned her passion for managing short-term vacation rentals into a thriving business. With a growing portfolio of over 15 carefully curated properties, Coastal Joy Vacation Rentals is dedicated to creating exceptional guest experiences in beautiful coastal destinations. Book with Caihlin, a 5-star host known for going above and beyond to make every stay effortless and unforgettable. Your vacation is in excellent hands—enjoy seamless check-in, exceptional communication, and thoughtful touches throughout. Best of all, there are no cleaning or checkout chores—just relax and savor every moment. You’ll leave refreshed, not rushed, and already planning your return.

Rare Premium Amenity: No-See-Um & Mosquito Control System:
Loggerhead Cay offers a high-end Mosquito Masters misting system using MistAway essential-oil-based products to help reduce no-see-ums and mosquitoes around the property. This is a rare amenity that many complexes do not offer and is a major added benefit for guests who want to enjoy Sanibel’s outdoor lifestyle more comfortably. The system uses biodegradable products that are EPA-registered and designed for responsible outdoor pest control. It helps create a more enjoyable experience on balconies, walkways, and common outdoor areas—one more reason Loggerhead Cay is such a great place to book.

Easy Checkout – Relax to the Very End. Your vacation should feel effortless—even when it’s time to leave. At #354, there are no cleaning check-out chores. All we ask is that you run the final dishwasher load and take out the trash—we’ll handle the rest. Leave refreshed, not rushed.

Toll to go onto Sanibel Island via the Sanibel Causeway is $6 for a standard 2-axle vehicle if using a transponder. If you don’t have a transponder (toll-by-plate) it’s $9. SunPass, EzPass and others will work for the $6 rate.

Loggerhead Cay Perks
- Designated Free Parking + Guest Parking: Each reservation includes one designated parking spot, along with additional complimentary guest parking available onsite.
- Free High‑Speed Wi-Fi (up to 500 Mbps): Perfect for streaming, remote work, and staying connected during your stay.
- Free Xfinity Cable: Enjoy a full lineup of cable entertainment options on the in‑unit TV.
- Beach Equipment Provided: Beach chairs, umbrellas, and other essentials are available for guest use.
- Water Oasis Garden: A peaceful outdoor garden area ideal for relaxing, dining, or unwinding beneath the pergola—located conveniently near the propane grills for outdoor meals.
- Tennis & Pickleball Courts: Enjoy onsite tennis and pickleball courts. Paddles, balls, and rackets are provided for guest use.
- Shelling Stations: Two designated shell‑cleaning stations make it easy to rinse and organize your treasures from the beach.
- Bike Racks
- In‑Unit Washer & Dryer: Private washer and dryer for guest use—no need to share laundry facilities.
- E-Bike Charging Stations on property!
- The property is best suited for a maximum of 4 adults. Additional guests may include children, but the total occupancy may not exceed 6 people due to HOA rules.
- Rare Premium Amenity: No-See-Um & Mosquito Control System

We provide all beach equipment needed for fun in the sun!!
- 4 low beach chairs & 2 high style beach chairs
- CoolCabana - easy to use shaded tent
- 1 umbrella
- Beach cart to carry it all down
- soft cooler
- 6 beach towels
- pack n play
- 2 Pickleball Paddles & Balls

May - October is Turtle nesting season. There are Amber lights throughout the community.