Property has an amazing location near the Casey Key Fish Restaurant (also with great tiki bar & boat rental / boat taxi service). Whilst old and only maintained to a basic / old fashioned level, it is nice 3 bed place with a small pool and everything that you need including groceries, towels, toys for kids, games etc (washer/dryer/fridge/dishwasher) etc all new.
The main reason we picked the house was to enjoy the private beach that is around 800 ft long and only used by 3 or 4 houses. Otherwise the high price (over 750 a day in peak) wouldn't make sense for an old unstylish house.
Unfortunately we had a significant "red ride effect" whilst we were there with 50-100 dead fish being washed up on the beach each day and one rough sea day with 300+ dead fish covering the beach. The sea removed the 50-100 dead fish but not the other fish, so that after a couple of days there were rotting fish all with the associated problems (terrible smell, flies, scavenger animals etc).
We didn't get any help from the home-owner, so we had to clean up the rotting fish ourselves because the smell was so bad, plus the associated risks to our kids especially our 18 month year old.
The home-owner was nice but a little intrusive, coming by too many times, and we were expected to do our own pool servicing, accommodate him showing prospective renters around, & have construction during our stay.
Also owner reengaged on pre-arranged late checkout & tried to circumvent vrbo and add extra fees etc