Pros
1. Keuka is very scenic and peaceful. For boaters there is minimal boat traffic and at least on this end of the lake the water is really calm most of the time. It was phenomenal for waterskiing and wakeboarding, etc.
2. The property is conveniently located like a mile away from Hammondsport which is a very nice quaint town. Nice shops, restaurants and a decent grocery store.
3. It is right on the water, really cool.
4. Plenty of space for 8 people.
5. Very clean and for the most part comfortable.
6. The deck is great for hanging out, fishing or swimming; as long as you don't have a boat.
7. The property owners are very nice. They used to allow dogs but no longer do (VRBO made that confusing for me) Because of that, they generously agreed to allow my sister's dog for an additional $75 cleaning fee. We were extemely appreciative.
Cons (mainly for boaters)
1. Most of the beds are uncomfortable. I would describe them as hard/stiff. The purchase of some decent mattress toppers would go a long way to provide comfort for most sleepers.
2. Based on several photos posted on VRBO (which have been removed due to my complaint) and written correspondence I had with Delia, we were lead to believe the dock could accomodate our 23' boat. When I asked the depth of the water where "we would dock our boat" I was told 20'. Much to our surprise when I pulled up with our expensive boat, I was told the dock (which is located at the edge of the rental property, next to their private home) was off limits. It's their private brand new dock. They no longer allow renters to dock, fish nor swim off it. Our dock was the deck. We had to dock our boat, horizontal to the lake. Since our boat pretty much stretched the length of the deck, we could not fish nor swim off of it. This situation was not desireable for what we were looking for in a lake property.
Overall, I would say this is a decent place to stay. We will definitely come back to Keuka Lake. The daily rental fee is very reasonable for a lake property given what we have paid over many years. As you can see there are very nice reviews of this place. However, if you have a boat this place may not meet your needs. All depends on what you are expecting to do off the deck.