We spent 2 weeks at Teresa and Charles house and had a wonderful time. It is conveniently located midway from the northern/southern ends of Long Island.
Spacious, clean, it has everything we needed + the beautiful view on the quiet waters of the “Sound” (you can walk but not swim the water there, because it is so shallow), with sunset to enjoy every night.
The large lot offers privacy, convenient stores are a 5/10 mn drive.
Long Island has plenty of amazing beaches on both the Carabeen and Atlantic sides, with incredible transparent turquoise and blue waters, superfine sand to walk on for miles, and we (almost) always had them just for us ! Truly beautiful. Just basically try any road (bumpy) left or right from the HQ, there are much more incredible sites than marked on the maps.
Teresa and Charles were very easy to work with, and they also offer boat and land tours if you want to go snorkeling or fishing.