This cabin is in the perfect spot! You are ON the water and a short drive to Eastsound. Just a lovely little neighborhood. As a STR owner myself, I would probably update some things, but it is as advertised. It is an older cabin and there were no surprises for us from the listing. The sulphur smell was quite strong, but we knew that would be the case going in. Overall, I think the place would benefit from a purifier attachment to the shower, some updated ceiling paint, updated kitchen wares, etc... but I gave the full five stars because it was as listed. And again you won't beat the location and price!