The only star I took was under "Cleanliness" we had bug issues in the loft bed - the only bed in this cabin (Cabin 6). The loft bed butts right up to a window so, obviously critters can come and go as they please, in the bed! We had a spider in the bed, two wood roaches, and 5 (what I thought was) baby wood roaches. I totally understand the outdoors and cabin setting will have bugs which is why we would absolutely stay again (and because everything else was 100% perfect) but, if you have any phobias of spiders or bugs maybe think about a different cabin that doesn't have the bed setup right next to the outside window. I don't know if being sprayed by an exterminator would get rid of the issue since it is nature!
Other than that, as stated above, everything was perfect! The cabin was VERY clean and well-kept. We were only in the cabin for sleeping because we were out hiking and enjoying the AMAZING weather (almost 80 in November!). There ended up being local cable which was nice at night. Having the private hot tub was absolutely amazing! We used it every chance we got. There was a mini fridge and stove top so if you are staying for a week food storage would probably be an issue. The cabin had a futon couch also if you are traveling with kids.
In the area there wasn't much, you had to drive about 30 minutes to get anywhere but there is some amazing things to do in the surrounding counties. We went to Marengo Caves and then hiked at Hemlock's Cliff. I would HIGHLY recommend both. The hike was beyond amazing! Then we went to French Lick Winery for dinner and a wine tasting.
We will definitely be coming back!