My family and friends have been going to Madeline Island for over 20 years. This was a great place to get away from all the fireworks in the big city over 4th of July. While I love them our dogs do not. One of our party stayed back with them while the rest of us went to see the Madeline Island fireworks show. We had a great time making new memories together, cooking, eating, playing games and enjoying each others company.
One of my critiques is that some of the mattresses on the beds could stand to be replaced. I understand that there is "Rustic Charm" but that shouldn't mean a mattress that feels like its 10-15 years old. Also, plumbing might need to be addressed, I've stayed at many places on the island over the years with septic systems and the water seemed to drain from both sinks very slowly. While it was awesome to breathe in fresh air, the occasional waft of raw sewage dampened the mood, but soon became a running joke among our crew.
Overall, we made the most of our time here and the pros definitely outweighed the time we spent joking about "fresh air".