This property lived up to all of our expectations in a way that far exceeded our actual expectations... It really was perfect in a way that couldn't have been expected.
The layout of the barn was great (and the architecture of it impressive). While it was just two of us and a dog, it was cozy, and it still had several bedrooms that went untouched. Everything was in great condition and it made for a nice, comfortable stay. It was also so well-equipped that we were able to make some big meals and have fun hanging out inside occasionally.
The property it is on was also great for us. The barn isn't far from the main house, but it still felt almost totally secluded. There was plenty of space to be outside walking around, playing with our dog, throwing horseshoes, sitting by the fire, etc. While not ideal for swimming when we were there (temperature and seaweed), the water access was incredible. We were also greeted one evening by a deer right in the back, which was surprising and fun.
This was our first time on Islesboro and we really fell in love with it. It had a really interesting vibe, beautiful scenery, nice little hikes/nature walks, and so on. While amenities on the island were limited we still found everything we needed between stores on the mainland, the small groceries on island, and some free produce at the community center. The time it took to line up for the ferry was a bit of a surprise, but it ended up just being part of the experience and a chance to look through pictures, read, etc.
This was exactly the vacation we needed, and we would love to go back to Roger and Maddie's barn to do it again!