Overall the rental was very good for us and what we were looking for. We spent a lot of time in the pool / lanai area. The pool could have been a touch warmer but overall it was refreshing once in the pool (wasn't for the lack of heat / sunshine...air temps were in the mid to upper 80's). We made full use of the lounge chairs by the pool and the table & chairs next to the pool. The dock area was very nice when we had a private chartered boat day-trip that was able to come there and pick us up for our day out on the ocean. We could drink out on the water without any fear of having to drive anywhere to get home. The furnishings in the house are a little sparse, there's only a very large (and nice) leather sectional sofa in the living room. Could have used a few chairs. We bought an inexpensive floor mat to put down inside the dining room area for the doorway leading from the pool to the house, otherwise with the ceramic tile any little amount of moisture was leading to very slippery floors. I don't recall if we left it there but if so hopefully it stays in use because it made a huge difference. The beds were fairly comfortable, we got a good night's sleep most of the time. We didn't use the grill, but we did point out to the property manager that the grill was broken (the left side shelf was loose and fell off when we took the cover off to inspect it). The bolts that hold it in place need repair, which hopefully the property manager does have taken care of. She did take pictures of the issue. The dishes, glasses, and cookware were sufficient, although the sink could use a drainer to put hand-washed dishes in to have them dry. We couldn't find a second garbage bag for our garbage but managed to make the one we had work for our stay...hopefully more are provided for the next renters. Also, we were left with 1 dishwashing tablet to start our stay...we bought a bag of them and left them there so hopefully the next renter gets full use of them, as well as the hand soap we bought for the 2nd bathroom, because what was in their dispenser was quite gross, honestly. We never had a physical check out either...we had to leave at 5:30 AM on our final day and the property manager never made any arrangements with us after we told her when we were leaving.
Overall, we enjoyed our stay and this rental suited our needs fairly nicely. There's just a few little items that would be easy to fix that could make this an outstanding rental.