The ReelParadise cabin lives up to its billing ... especially with kids. My wife and I had the pleasure of staying along with our 8 and 4 year old. There were ample toys already there. We enjoyed playing board games, watching movies, and most of all, the kids enjoyed the swing. Who knew? They spent over six hours (across a couple of days) playing together on a SWING! Kitchen is well outfitted with quality (not Ikea) cooking tools. Lots of wonderful glassware, great selection of plastic and ceramic plates. Downstairs bed was huge and very comfortable. Kids love the bunk beds upstairs. The owners have done a great job. Nothing felt 'cheap' and it really enhanced our enjoyment feeling like this was a home way from home.
A few notes - AC is all window units, and that can overpower the breaker. You have to pack-out your trash (though the cleaning lady offered to take ours, which was very nice). You DO NOT have to do a floor-to-ceiling cleaning on checkout, as we've been asked to do at other places, but keep the place nice, and get a load or two of laundry done to help out (towels and sheets). This isn't a "view" property, but the front yard is ample, and the street is incredibly quiet. You'd be lucky to have 2 cars pass by a day.
I highly recommend this cabin. We've stayed in about a dozen places, and this is the best place we've stayed at in Arizona.
Overgaard is well placed for trips to Woods Canyon/Willow Canyon Lake, we also visited Fools Canyon Lake in Showlow. An hour away is Petrified National Forrest, and a lot more. Restaurants are a bit hit or miss - especially during the week - but everyone is nice. We had a nice hour trail ride with the kids, hosted by Robert at the stables right next to the Wild Women Saloon (try the fried pickles - they were solid).