This was our first visit to the Point Reyes station area, and we weren't quite sure what to expect. The lodging options were few and far between, and when we found the Mermaid Cottage, we were pretty excited- no frilly B&B atmosphere, right on the water, not too far (15 minute drive) from Pt Reyes Station. For the most part, the area and the cottage lived up to our expectations. Fred was very helpful from start to finish. The cottage was clean and cute, and with an unbeatable location on the water. We had been advised before booking that the sleeping area was in a loft space, with a low ceiling and accessed by a steep stair/ladder -it all worked out well for us, but the ladder might pose some challenges for some guests.
A few aspects of the cottage could use some upgrades which would make it more enjoyable: It could really use a new tv, maybe add an iPod docking station or Bluetooth speaker, and replace the oldest appliances in the kitchen. Also, the folder with helpful local contacts/businesses was from 2006, so not too helpful.
Given the seemingly high nightly rate, maybe we just expected more. It wouldn't take much to make this cottage worth every penny- it really is a great spot for a weekend getaway to a beautiful area. We thoroughly enjoyed our visit overall .