My 4-stars for this visit is primarily because it was incredibly convenient being within the park boundaries and only ~35 minutes from Tunnel View, otherwise this cabin was very different than what I expect from a typical VRBO. This whole review needs clarification that I have different expectations with a VRBO than with a cabin rental company, especially when I know that Yosemite rentals probably get used hard through the summer. That said, prior to arrival I knew there was a management group, but I didn't fully understand this is not exactly a true VRBO private home experience. When you arrive you have to check in at the office to get your keys, so I'm glad we arrived during office hours because I don't know what happens otherwise? Once we got into the cabin we noticed a chair with a broken leg right away and the place definitely wouldn't be considered very clean but it's a cabin so we overlooked lots of that. Then it seemed there were many simple amenities missing. We barely had enough towels for our small group, there were no spices including salt&pepper, there wasn't a baking sheet but the 'housekeeping' provided one from the office only after I had to explain to the front desk why I would need one, and a kitchen drawer was broken before we ever used it... again, for an outdoorsy cabin in Yosemite this may be expected but I was anticipating this feeling like a VRBO-quality experience in terms of the housing. Now, with all of this said, we did still absolutely love the location, the property staff was kind, and being close to the little village market made it easy to buy spices/paper towels/etc. I just wouldn't consider this experience what I hope to get from a VRBO.