Charming Beachfront Cottage on Historic Registry

Thank you for recommending Reel Simple. We’re glad you enjoyed the home, convenient beach access, and easy check-in, and we appreciate you sharing your experience.

Thank you for the kind review. We’re glad you enjoyed the property and would be happy to welcome you back!

Thank you for the kind review. We’re glad you and your family enjoyed the beach and your time together at Reel Simple. We hope to welcome you back in the future.

Harriett, thank you for the feedback!

Thank you so much for the wonderful review! We're thrilled to hear that you and your family enjoyed the cozy ambiance and the stunning ocean views. It's our pleasure to provide a comfortable and enjoyable experience for our guests. We appreciate your kind words and look forward to welcoming you back in the future.

Thank you for your wonderful feedback! We're delighted you enjoyed the porches, the beach access, and the proximity to local restaurants. We hope to welcome you back soon.

Thank you for the kind words! We are so glad you enjoyed your stay, and we can't wait to see you back again soon!

Thank you for the kind words! We are so glad you enjoyed your stay, and we can't wait to see you back again soon!

Thank you for the review! Reel Simple is such a special home! We are glad you enjoyed your stay! We hope to see you again soon!

Thank you for your feedback. We're glad you enjoyed the location. We apologize for the bed issue and have secured those slats. We appreciate your understanding and hope to welcome you back soon.

Shay, thank you so much for your kind words! This charming, historic home is perfect for those in need of a lovely ocean front view, while also taking a step back into history. The owners have truly made this house memorable with all the antiques and collectibles on display. We're glad you enjoyed your stay and will continue to come back and visit us!

Thank you for your review of our 100-year-old home. We're glad to hear that you felt like a kid again and that the property was a perfect fit for you. We appreciate your understanding that a historic home may require a bit more upkeep, and we're grateful for the positive memories you've shared. Your feedback is valuable, and we'll continue to do our best to maintain the charm and character of this unique property. Thank you for your visit, and we hope you'll consider staying with us again in the future.

Thank you Leslie for that review! Many people have expressed how it reminds them of going to a beach house when they were growing up, including myself. We hope you'll make it your fourth year next year and we will see you then!

Tammy, thank you so much for the wonderful review! We are so glad to hear you enjoyed your stay! We hope to see you again soon!

Patrick, thank you so very much for the thoughtful review! We agree, Reel Simple is definitely not for everyone, but for those looking for old school charm or to bring their grandparents on a vacation that reminds them of yesteryear, Reel Simple is the place to be! We are glad you enjoyed your stay! Come back again soon!

Great to hear, Jennifer! You're welcome back anytime!

Please do, Jim! Happy 75th to the mother-in-law!

Michelle, welcome back! Thank you for the kind words! We agree, Reel Simple really does deliver a vintage beach experience! It is one of a kind. We are so glad you enjoyed your stay, and we can't wait to see you back again soon!

Hi Joe, thank you for the feedback. We will take your feedback into consideration, but firmly do not believe our listing has any false advertising. It stays the pet policy "Pet Policy: Pets welcome with fee of $200 per pet." It doesn't state all pets, simply "Pets welcome." Since all of our reservations are pending the review of the rental contract, the same applies to the pet fee. We are sorry this affected your stay, but stand by listing and believe it is fairly advertised. We wish we could make the weather beautiful every day, I know the weather the week of Christmas was definitely not ideal beach weather. Overall, we wish you the best with your future stays!

Dennis, it's great to hear that you enjoyed all the wonderful charm Reel Simple offers! This historic beach cottage is a treat for those who want to get away and relax in a secluded area. The home has ample bedrooms and beds to comfortably sleep larger groups without losing that old-school vibe with the sinks in each room! Glad you loved it and we hope to see you back again soon.

Thank you so much for this great and very descriptive review! This house is such a popular rental with the history, amenities and fantastic location and views. We hope you will make Reel Simple your vacation spot year after year!

John, thank you for your feedback on Reel Simple. We are sorry to hear you had a couple issues and would have loved the opportunity to correct them if you had made us aware! All are easy fixes that maintenance could have taken care of that day as they are on call 24/7. We stock coffee makers at the office and the owner would pay for that replacement had you not bought one yourself. We never heard of any issues with the coffee makers not working and have been renting the property for a bit of time. The unit already had its spring clean this year which is an intensive deep cleaning of the unit and everything in it. It is an older historical cottage, so it's age may make it feel unclean, even if it is clean. We will make note of your feedback and suggestions to relay to the owner. We are happy to hear you enjoyed your vacation nonetheless and have other historical homes on the island you could try next time if you'd like.

Hi Robert. Thank you for your feedback on Reel Simple. We are glad you've been visiting this house for so many years. I am sorry you had some issues with the floors and we were happy that you reported it as quickly as you did so we could address that right away by sending one of our best housekeeping staff to re-clean, and one of our hospitality leaders there to make sure you were satisfied with the results. I will pass along your suggestion of updates that you feel are needed in the house to the owners for them to consider in the future.

Thank you Karyn for the great review! We are so glad you continue making family memories in Reel Simple through the years and we hope you will be back soon!

Mary, we really appreciate your feedback on this historic and unique home. I do hope you were able to enjoy the close proximity to the beach and beautiful ocean view from the porches. I apologize there were issues that occurred during your stay, but I assure you that I have passed on your comments to both our hospitality and maintenance departments in order to correct these issues for future guests. As far as the appliances, we do have procedures in place to discuss these things with our owners. I will be sure to send your comments up the ladder so that it can be discussed accordingly. We take feedback very seriously, so we thank you for giving us the opportunity to constantly improve our guests' experiences. We hope you'll consider staying with us again for your next vacation!