Montauk family rentals

We stayed for a week with our small dog. Before arrival, Danny was extremely responsive with any questions and check in was a breeze. The cottage was very welcoming and decorated in charming nautical decor. The location is serene and private, with beautiful water views and plenty of outdoor space in the yard area. The cottage was clean, well-equipped, and perfect for a relaxing escape. The location was great too! Highly recommend for anyone looking to unwind in Montauk!

We had an amazing weekend at the Connelly's. It's rare to find such a perfectly appointed, impeccably clean, beautifully decorated home with a direct ocean view in a perfect location across from the beach. The complex is very clean and quiet with a lovely pool and common area. Walk to downtown if you choose, explore the area - so much to enjoy! Fantastic owners were immediately responsive to any questions or needs. Check in was a breeze. We will be back for sure!

We so enjoyed our stay! The view from the property is spectacular, so we were able to enjoy the beach even though we had bad weather. The size was great - we were four adults and fit comfortably. Tim was an excellent host, who promptly assisted us with any questions we had. We will be looking to stay here again!

We thoroughly enjoyed staying here, short walk to town, beautiful scenery, quiet and clean.

Staying at Kelly’s lakefront property in Montauk was truly a healing experience. From the moment we arrived, the serene surroundings washed away the stress of daily life. The house was spotless and beautifully maintained, with every amenity thoughtfully provided. Whether sipping coffee on the deck in the mornings or winding down with a book as the sun set, the peace and tranquility here are unparalleled. Kelly thought of everything to make our stay so much more enjoyable and special, that we didn’t even need anything. Despite feeling like a secluded retreat, the property is just a short drive from town, making it easy to explore Montauk's charming shops and restaurants. This place isn't just a rental—it's a restorative escape that nurtures the soul. We left feeling rejuvenated and can't wait to return.

Wish we could have stayed longer! House was perfect. Host was lovely! Thank you!

My wife and I were looking for a relaxing break immediately following our wedding. This property was perfect. The hosts provided everything needed. The space was quaint and comfortable, extremely clean, secure, the property was beautiful with lake front access and hosts provided beach parking pass. Close to Montauk state park and close to town. Perfect spot for a couples retreat. We will be back.

The house was fantastic as were the owners which made for a wonderful week. Proximity to town, access to the beach, and the house itself makes this an ideal place to spend a vacation in Montauk. Kids loved the large yard just as much as the beach! Everything was better than advertised and communication with the owner was easy and effective.