This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Recent Key Colony Beach reviews

  • Plenty of Pros, a few Cons

    "We just got home from our stay here and figured we would share our experience. Overall we had an amazing stay and would definitely return. There were plenty of Pros, and a few Cons to this rental. Pros- 1- The location was perfect. We never stayed in Key Colony Beach before and when we return we will definitely be staying there. There were a few great restaurants within walking distance, our favorite being Sparky's Landing which we went to 4 times. 2- Access to the Cabana Club was a huge bonus. It was great for the days you wanted to just lounge around and drink by (or in) the pool or go to the beach. The food and drinks there were all great and very reasonably priced. The beach there was also very well maintained and had very little if any sea grass. 3- THE BACK YARD!- The back yard was amazing and was perfect for fishing and sight seeing. We caught a ton of fish right off the dock like snapper, grunts, catfish, and a few others we couldn't identify. We were also visited daily by some manatee which the kids loved and saw sting rays, barracuda, and some Sargent Majors directly under the dock. We brought our kayak and paddle board and enjoyed nightly sunset paddles. 3-The property manager (Barry I believe) was extremely attentive to any issues we had and was over within minutes to help. 4-Garage storage space!- we couldn't find many other units that had this amenity and allowed us to store our bicycles and fishing equipment in. 5- Included a garage full of goodies to use including 3 kayaks, bicycles, tons of fishing equipment and tackle, life jackets etc. Everything was in much better shape than what we expected from a vacation rental. 6-The master bed was amazing. It was some sort of memory foam mattress and both my wife and I slept amazing while there. There was also an abundance of towels, linens etc, that were great. Cons- 1- The toilet in the master bath was kind of wobbly. We were afraid we were going to tip over when we first got there but got used to it by the end. 2-the kitchen faucet is extremely loose and not well fitted. We were afraid it was going to rip off whenever we washed dishes or our hands. A simple tightening of the nut under the sink should fix it. 3- the couches in the living room are extremely worn and could be replaced. That being said they were very comfortable and I actually fell asleep on one the first night which I haven't done in ages. The Pros definitely outweigh the cons for this unit and we will definitely ret"
    Guest: Nicole C. Date of Stay: June 2016 Review Submitted: June 27, 2016
    View listing
  • AWESOME place...extremely clean

    "I have never taken the time to write a review before but this place deserves one! First off the owner Jillian was wonderful and personable to deal with as was Holli the property manager who greeted us upon our arrival and answered any questions we had throughout our stay. From start to finish the process was very easy and accommodating. I was extremely pleased with the cleanliness of this truly was IMMACULATE. The furnishings and decorating were very welcoming along with comfortable beds and new washer and dryer set...(nice to keep up with the laundry so you don't have a ton when you get home). Loved the Cabana Club and the location of this home. The dock was great, we saw manatees and tarpon right around our boat and tons of lizards and iguanas running around! We took our cleaned filleted fish we caught to Key Colony Inn and they gave us about 12 to15 different options to prepare it for us, our youngest recommends the sicilian way...yummy. No Name Pub, Sombrero Reef, Fishing with Main Attraction, lobstering, snorkling, Burdines, Sparkys, bike riding in Key West and Swimming with the Dolphins at Theater of the Sea completed our stay....We will definitely be back to stay at Jillian's lovely home again. Thank you for allowing us to stay! T. Koss Sarasota, Fl."
    Guest: Teri S. Date of Stay: July 2016 Review Submitted: August 17, 2016
    View listing
  • Stayed During Hurricane Matthew!

    "My daughter and I stayed the week of Hurricane Matthew. Luckily everything in the keys was fine and the weather was just gorgeous. I have to say that Sheli was very accommodating when our flight through Fort Lauderdale was cancelled and Kristen in the office worked with us very closely to monitor the situation. We were incredibly lucky to not only have beautiful accommodations, but people who were looking out for our well being. Everyone was so caring and kind. The condo was beautiful and the grounds were lovely. There's tons to do in the area and lots of great restaurants. The beach and pool were terrific! I can't say enough!!!"
    Guest: FamilyWithTwins Date of Stay: September 2016 Review Submitted: October 10, 2016
    View listing
  • A wonderful stay.

    "We go to the Keys once or twice a year and usually stay in Key Colony Beach. We like to try different houses and six of us stayed at this property the first week of June, 2016. Although it was too windy to chase mahi mahi we had a ball. We caught fish every day. The managers were very friendly, accommodating and knowledgeable."
    Guest: Thomas N. Date of Stay: June 2016 Review Submitted: June 17, 2016
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement