Firstly, we loved the cabin and the location. I rated cleanliness at three because of the master bathroom smell, the carpets, cobwebs in the living room on the bench and sticky vinyl floors. There is an outside flood lamp that is hanging by the wire. I know this is just a vacation rental but this cabin needs some love before the reputation starts to slip. Invest a little now in solid stain for the porches or lot latter when they need to have deck boards replaced. We will definitely consider a return visit. I posted a 5 star overall rating because I appreciate your space. The bike shed was great. We did not use the grill or the fire pit. The master bathroom, frankly, was gross.