Beautiful , upscale historic home new to the short term rental market
Every inch of this historic home has been restored. 6 Private bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, large eat in kitchen, dining room, game room, and living room. Home boasts a large yard and fire pit. Walkable to downtown, but remains private.We have 3 Queen, 1 King, and 2 full beds.
Our prices include all fees. No hidden fees.
Add dates for prices
Have a question?
AI iconBetaBeta
Get instant answers with AI powered search of property information and reviews.
Similar properties
Spacious 5-bedroom/4.5 bath house in the charming Bay Point Resort and Marina.
Lakeside Marblehead
Spacious 5-bedroom/4.5 bath house in the charming Bay Point Resort and Marina.
Put-in-Bay is home to this holiday home. Lake Erie Islands Historical Society and Liberty Aviation Museum are cultural highlights, and some of the area's attractions include Perry's Cave and Kimberly's Carousel. Island Adventures Family Fun Center and The Watering Hole Safari and Waterpark are also worth visiting.
The Pink Catawba house was a great place to stay! It was painted pink right before we arrived! The owners were wonderful to work with - communication was excellent and check-in was seamless.The house was incredibly clean and beautifully decorated with a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Every detail was thoughtfully done, making it feel like a true home away from home.Would definitely stay here again and excited to plan our next visit! Highly recommend to anyone looking for a spotless, comfortable rental with fantastic owners!
Caitlin F.
Stayed 3 nights in Jul 2025
Response from VrboOwner on 22 Jul 2025
Thank you Caitlin for taking such good care of our home and being 5 star guests! We appreciate you choosing our home for your celebration.
Group of 8 women, several enjoying first time to Put-in-Bay including 86 year old checking off a trip on her bucket list.
We found the property exceptionally clean, well supplied in kitchen, bedrooms and game room.
A very lovely home that was quite nice & we had a good time.
The most glaring problem was no hot tub as promised on the web site & no propane in the tank.
Other issues are not enough bathrooms for 12 people. Needs at least another 1/2 bath downstairs, especially not isolated to a suite. There is also not enough eating spaces together at a table except outside. Perhaps smaller chairs at dining room would allow at least 10 at a time, if the end spaces are utilized. Outside doors/exits that are not user friendly also is a safety issue. And only 1 tv with that many people staying is not very good either. Windows painted over & others that wouldn't close were an issue for the bedrooms
The record player was a hit with the teenagers fascinated by the workings & us oldsters approving of the music. The beds were very comfortable.
Mary,
Thank you for your stay.
The home was never listed with a hot tub as discussed in our conversations, so I am unsure where you got that information. I never stated there was a hot tub or posted a picture that there was one on the property. I apologize again if that affected your stay.
There was additional propane on the property, all you needed to do was contact me and I would have gotten it for you. As a host, I cannot fix a problem that I am not aware of.
The spaces are correctly advertised and if you felt that the bathrooms would not have accommodated your group, you should have picked another home better suited perhaps.
Unsure what user friendly/ safety issues you are referring to concerning the doors? A small deck still needs built outside the side door, so it is blocked off because that is a safety issue…There are still 4 other doors leading outside.
All the windows function in the home as well, some easier than others as one would expect with an home of that age, with the exception of a few downstairs windows that are very difficult to open and I do not have screens for.
The 84 inch television was our decision vs multiple ones everywhere in the home to preserve the feel of the home, and as most travel with a tablet or computer if TV watching is a priority for them.
Glad you found the turntable and records fun!
I appreciate your input on needing an additional bathroom ( if there was a feasible spot, it would be there) as you know we have fully updated the upstairs full bath and added a powder room upstairs as well.
The dining room comfortably seats 8 and there is an additional dining room table, just a few feet away in the game room, for an additional 4. Having a dining room that has room for a table for 12 would be great, but unfortunately I do not have room for a table that size.
You were our first VRBO customer. I appreciate that. We have spent the last 2.5 years updating and upgrading the home, and there are a few projects to be finished, we are very pleased with the space.
Thanks again.