Pros,
If you are looking to find a way to find peace and tranquility. Hope Town is a cross between a Norman Rockwell picture and a Hallmark Movie (so I'm told by my wife). Quaint and quiet! We thoroughly enjoyed our stay. The house was neat and orderly, the location was right off the dock. The view and location was worth every cent. Couldn't have asked for a better place!
Cons: (2 issues)
The first issue we had was the wireless. Even though we were on vacation, this was a big deal for us, We own a company and still had daily issues we had to work on. The wireless never worked the entire time we were there. Had to use our hotspot on our phones. (Expensive, but unavoidable).
Second issue was the loss of water. Electricity went off several times a day. That was not a problem. The pump, however, was. In order to get water back into the house, the water pump had to primed every time electricity came back on. We texted the manager to come show us how to get the pump primed, but no one ever showed up. Fortunately, I have been around this equipment most of my life and was able to prime it myself. Had I not been able to do so, we would have been without water for hours at a time.
All-in-all, the trip was wonderful. Even with those two negative issues, we would return without hesitation. Loved Hope Town and the place we stayed. If you decided to go, rent a boat, over a golf cart. Boating around to the other Islands was the best part of our trip.