I cannot say enough about our experience. We wanted to get away as a family (of five), something that was laid back and relaxed, but with lots to do when we wanted it. We live in a quite modern house and were looking for something with a similar vibe.
Montauk is one of our favorite locations and we have stayed a week there a few times already. This location was located near "Ditch Beach," I believe it is the last beach on your way to Montauk point so it feels intimate, without large crowds or parking lots. You will see lots of surfers (it seems to be a kind of "surfer beach") of all ages. From kids that looked to be 2 or 3 years perched at the tip of their parent's board to people who seem to have been living the surfing life into old age. It takes maybe five minutes to walk or 2 minutes to drive to the beach from the property.
We were pleasantly surprised several times. We brought our own bikes only to find that property actually already comes with access to four bikes. We brought beach chairs and then found that the storage space under the deck is stacked with chairs, some surf boards, a boogie board, umbrella, etc.
The house's construction is remarkably solid and high quality, from windows and doors to the gas fireplace and three outdoor decks. There is a spacious office space at the very top half-floor from which you can work quietly.
The entrance way and landscaping is the first thing you see. It is well maintained and creates a nice privacy barrier, with tall hedges separating the front lawn from the gravel parking area. Not that the street is busy at all.
One of our favorite features was the outdoor shower, wrapped in wood, in which you can take a hot, strong shower under the Hampton's famously beautiful sky, toward sunset, after a day in the sand.
The owner, Christopher, was really helpful and responsive. He lives nearby, built the house for his family, and raised his kids there so knows the area and provides some good "inside" tips as part of the house manual.
We will definitely be back.