My wife and I spent almost two weeks in Maui at this apartment. The location, a ground floor apartment on the beach, was great. The apartment itself was passable, but only just.
Pros:
Location. We could walk out of sliding doors to the beach in under 30 seconds. The beach itself was clean and pleasant. Breakfast on the patio was fantastic.
Amenities. The apartment is furnished with most of what you need, from a washer/drier, dishwasher, pots and pans, a wide assortment of utensils, to good internet, etc.
Cons.
We found the check-in (and check-out) process to be somewhat irritating. Over communication about the rules and warnings, a requirement to constantly send updated travel information, ongoing marketing emails while you’re there and afterwards (I eventually unsubscribed), and a strong push to get you out of the apartment ASAP the last morning (“please feel free to select your checkout time from 6AM - 10AM!). The tone always implied Aloha, but each step in the communication process benefited just the manager/owner and eventually became a pebble in our vacation shoes.
Cleanliness. Maui is expensive. Surely for that price you could afford to do a periodic deep clean. Apartment was tidy and acceptably clean on the surface, but every corner is old and grimy. Windows and window sills need scrubbing. It smelled faintly of mildew. This was the dirtiest place I’ve stayed in a long time.
Updates. Similar to above. The fridge is dying and it constantly screams in its swan song. The first night we actually thought it was an animal outside the apartment. Plastic dishes. Old linens. It just seemed like someone’s dream apartment from 20 years ago, only now the dream was frayed and old.
We would absolutely go back to Maui. Despite the location and conveniences, we wouldn’t stay here. 3 stars.