We bought our house in Madaket after years of renting in Wauwinet at the very other side of the island. Madaket has a fun vibe that's great for families. It also has lots of pristine beaches. We like to go to the one down our street and then also explore the local roads to find access to the other ones that are more hidden but still close by. When it's open, we love going to Smith's Point, too, because you get an ocean beach and a harbor beach and it's great for picking up some scallop shells.
We also love the history in Nantucket - all the old homes - and the unique shops and fine dining. What's great about the island is that for all it stays the same, it's always changing, and there's always something going on in town. For a week's vacation for both relaxing and sightseeing there's no place we'd rather be in the summer! We're into our second decade of summering in Nantucket and still loving it! We bet you will, too!