My overall review is short: This is an excellent place--hard to imagine anyone who wants to stay in Sea Ranch not having a great experience.
My notes for others on this house (to try and be helpful):
Sea Ranch, as a whole, is one of the most lovely getaway spots anywhere. The drive up CA1 is worth the time alone, and the ocean-side houses and long meandering trails are the perfect way to relax. John has a great place right in the middle of Sea Ranch, and nicely close to the rec center/pool. It’s a great combination of functional along with that indescribable 70s era funkiness that I really enjoy. We had three generations sleep there for Christmas, and everyone was comfortable the whole time. The kitchen is stocked with plenty of dishes/flatware as well as cook pots/pans/implements/spices, the couches and chairs are very comfortable, and there are more bed/sleeping combinations possible with the upper level loft than is apparent at first blush. Additionally, the sheets and blankets on the beds are very comfortable, helping even the lighter sleepers in our crew stay blissfully asleep. This feels much more like a beloved family vacation house, used by grandparents and many little kids alike (check out the pile of games in the bedroom closet), than a sterile purpose-purchased and appointed Airbnb. I would go back anytime. The only pointer for others—bring a bag of ice (and a meal for your first night) from the Stewart’s Point store or the Gualala Surf Market on your way in, so you can enjoy a cocktail at sunset your first night; as well-appointed as the kitchen is, there is no food to make a meal on check-in (including no cooking oil, coffee, ketchup, and other fridge dwelling condiments).
Overall, I was very impressed with the house, and would absolutely stay here again. Jon was very communicative about setting expectations, check-in, and progress, and we tried to be as respectful as possible of his very lovely home.