Brian and Tracy have a wonderful house located just outside Wyndham, NY - approximately 7 minutes. If you want to feel like you are in the woods, the house will accommodate. If you want to be close to town, the house will also accommodate (though you can't walk to town).
They have the house stocked with everything you would need, including, most impressively, a well appointed kitchen with quality tools.
The beds were comfortable, the living room was cozy, and there was plenty of room to spread out from each other.
We went skiing so we were up there in snow and cold and the house was great. From the "mud room" type area where we would stash our boots and jackets, to the warmth of the heaters, the house was comfortable. As far as summer time, the house is a two minute bike ride from the Elm Ridge mountain biking system.
Finally, Brian was responsive to questions and pleasant to deal with.