As far as big picture stuff, this place was amazing!!! You can't find a better value this close to downtown. The place was clean, comfortable, and there were no surprises. We walked to Scottsdale stadium, downtown, and groceries. All the other places I looked at for this trip were much more expensive. We had trouble getting in and Tom had the neighbor there within a few minutes and we were in the house.
Here's where I get super critical on smaller details that I think would have earned the 5th star. The doorknob had a little trick to it and I think it would be beneficial to include that in the check-in instructions. If we had been stumbling in at midnight I think all parties involved would not be happy. I couldn't find a bike pump anywhere and the tires were low. I rode it to get groceries but it would be nice to have instructions on where the pump is. One of the shower heads is old and leaves much to be desired. The other one is the kind you can hold in your hand but it doesn't really fit in the holster when you go to put it up.
Like I said, big picture stuff is great and I would book this place again in a heartbeat. You know a place is good when the only thing I can find to criticize is bike pumps, doorknobs, and shower-heads.