The location, lake are pristine. You could not find a cleaner beach or lake in northern Wisconsin, i cannot stress this enough, it was supreme. The cabin was good for what we needed, it was as clean as you would expect, the layout worked for what it is, two kitchens, fridges, icemaker are all great, and having high chairs was an incredibly helpful thing when traveling with a child under 1 y/o. The pontoon was a nice touch, we loved using it, its an older model and a little beat up but for cruising the lake it works and is still relaxing.
Things i wish were different.
The cabin is not adequately labeled, it looks like an admin building as it is attached to the motel where others are staying, it is not a separated cabin as the pictures show, and without adequate signage others will have the problem we did with guests of the motel walking in on our actual cabin where we were staying. This happened Multiple times and was annoying to be frank. People also walked on the deck from the motel and we had to effectively kick them off which created unneeded tension. Also, if a cabin comes with a pontoon, you should reserve that dock for those people. We had guests of the hotel sitting with their legs draped over both sides of our dock one night and they were not pleased that we were tying the pontoon on that dock, even though it was the same one where the pontoon was when we checked in. The Fire Pits need to be labeled as well. I would create signs or a map for guests to show which guests have access to which docks, fire pits, common areas, etc. it would remove a lot of confusion and concern.
All in all i will recommend to friends and other family, i cannot get over how clear the lake was and having the pontoon and fire pit was awesome, it made for a very enjoyable experience.