This was my third time staying at Toes in the Sand, and it was (as usual) delightful. Earl is super easy to communicate with, and prompt to respond to any issues. There were bottles of rum waiting for us when we arrived, and several different sunscreens we could use if we ran out. Earl takes hospitality seriously, and it shows!
This property is located right on the beach, and there's an extensive tire reef just a short swim from the shore where you can see at least dozens of different kinds of fish (squirrelfish, angelfish, blue tangs, porcupine fish, several varieties of grunts, lionfish, harlequin bass, several varieties of goatfish, red hinds, sand perch, butterflyfish, and more!) We were worried about the sargassum, but it wasn't as bad as we'd thought from the videos we saw shortly before the trip.
We'll be back to visit, and we will plan to rent this same unit again and again!