Our family of three (mom, dad, teen boy) just returned from 6 nights at this property. The cabin is very well built; we were impressed. It is a small space, which you should be able to tell from the listing. The pictures of the futon (which is actually a nice couch now) and the fold-out beds are a bit misleading since that space is not accessible from within the cabin. You need to enter via a door from the outside. That's cool, unless a guest was planning to sleep in the cabin's main bed and put their kids in the extra "bedroom," which is essentially a separate property with two doors only accessible from the outside.
The cabin layout is unique, and we were quite glad for the basement. We used the main cabin for sleeping (the loft was perfect for our son) and food storage/prep. However, the basement was more conducive to watching tv and eating our meals. So we carried our meals up and down the stairs, but after a day or two it became pretty normal. We also ended up using the basement bathroom for showering and getting ready because the shower is larger and there's a double vanity - much more space all around. So again, we carried our clothes back and forth as needed, but it worked out.
The space was clean, with the exception of an overlooked trashcan and sink trap in the basement. We enjoyed the oversized Connect Four game, and the wall Scrabble! We also really enjoyed the fire pit area on our last night.
I might suggest a few things for comfort's sake. I know mattresses and pillows are very subjective. But the firm mattress and flat pillows weren't a good combination for us, and after the second night neither my husband nor I could turn our heads. It worked out, but was a challenge early on. A plush mattress topper and some additional pillows of various types might add comfort. Also, in the upstairs bathroom there were a variety of bath towels, hand towels, and washcloths, but we could only find a small bar of hotel soap. In the basement we didn't find hand towels or washcloths, but there was body wash and conditioner, just no shampoo. These are tiny details, probably overly picky, but we've stayed in so many vacation rentals that do a great job of amenities, which we always appreciate.
All in all, this made a great base for exploring Asheville. We met Jeff the first night, and he was very kind! We also met the neighbor, who stopped by to say hello.