Overall, this house was a great place to stay! All of us agreed we'd rent it again, if there were an opportunity to do so.
Truly appreciated the response time I received in answer to my questions as well as the flexibility in possibly having to postpone the stay (due to weather conditions). In addition, the house really worked out well for our whole family. It was nicely decorated, well "stocked" with dishes, linens, cooking pans and utensils, etc. and was very spacious for all of us to spread out. A nice surprise was the the games and toys that were there for the kids to enjoy.
Had it been warm out, I'm sure sitting in the enclosed patio would have been very enjoyable, especially with the fenced-in yard that would have allowed the kids to safely play in the backyard.
If we had any complaint at all, it would be the request to strip the beds, run the dishwasher, take the garbage out, etc. For a one-night stay we felt the "cleaning fee" was a little steep. Granted the laundry used (ie bed sheets) were the same whether or not we stayed one night or more. However, the overall usage of everything else as well as the house not requiring a deep cleaning probably did not warrant the full cleaning fee. (BTW, only 3 of us used any bath towels so there wasn't a lot of towels to wash either.) I'd like to suggest a refund of a portion of that fee if the house is found to be in pretty much the same condition as the way it was before staying.
One suggestion: put blinds on the lav window! Using the downstairs lav at night was a little creepy...especially since the room is in the front of the house which means the neighbors and/or anyone driving by can see who is in the bathroom.
Other than that, we would definitely recommend this property for rent.