Coconut Castaway | Ocean Views, Golf Cart & Club Pool

Thank you for staying! We hope to host you again in the future :)

Thank you for staying and for the wonderful review! We hope to host you again in the future :)

Thank you so much for your 5-star review—we’re so glad you enjoyed the location and those beautiful views! We also really appreciate your feedback on the master bedroom bed. Comfort can be such a personal preference, and we’re always looking for ways to improve the experience for our guests. We’ll definitely take a closer look at this. Thanks again for staying with us—we’d love to welcome you back anytime!

Thank you so much for the wonderful review. We hope to host you again!

Thank you so much for the wonderful review! We’re so glad you had such a fun and memorable birthday trip. The ferry ride really does set the tone for the adventure to North Captiva Island, and we love hearing that you enjoyed exploring the island by golf cart and discovering the beautiful beaches and homes along the way. It sounds like you made the most of the stay—from shelling on the beach to taking in those sunrise and sunset views from the crow’s nest. Those views are one of our favorite parts of Coconut Castaway too! We also appreciate the helpful suggestion about having more kitchen items like zip-top bags and foil. Feedback like this helps us continue improving the experience for our guests. Next time you’ll just have to bring friends or family to help fill those extra bedrooms! We’d love to host you again for another island adventure. 🌴☀️

Thank you Colette - we're happy to hear you had a wonderful time and hope to host you again!

Thank you so much for this wonderful review! We’re thrilled to hear that Coconut Castaway was the perfect getaway to recharge after the busy holiday season. It sounds like you truly embraced island life—from sunrise and sunset views to beach walks, shell hunting, and daily manatee visits. We love hearing how much your family enjoyed Mangos, the pool, and even the basketball hoop, as well as the mix of dining out at Mainstay and grilling at home. We’re also so glad the home, décor, and cleanliness met your expectations and that our management team took great care of you. We would be absolutely delighted to welcome you back to Coconut Castaway next New Year’s. Thank you again for choosing our home and for sharing your experience! 🌴

Thank you so much for this lovely review! We’re thrilled to hear that Coconut Castaway was exactly what your family needed for a relaxing holiday break. It’s wonderful to know you enjoyed so many of our favorite parts of the home and island—from morning coffee and game nights on the lanai to sunsets from the crow’s nest. It sounds like you truly embraced the North Captiva lifestyle, and we’re so glad the club membership, golf cart, and peaceful island vibe were a perfect fit for your active adventures. We would be absolutely delighted to welcome you back for another stay in the future!

Thank you for your review Alberto - we're happy you enjoyed your stay!

Thank you for the wonderful review, Leslie! We're happy to hear you enjoyed your stay and definitely reach back out to us when you're ready to come back to the island!

We're happy to hear you enjoyed Coconut Castaway, and look forward to hosting you again for a future vacation!

Important context is missing from this review. This guest booked our home for 4 people but arrived on the island with 6 guests. Our listing plainly states that an accurate guest count is required because it determines the number of golf carts included with the reservation. One 4-person golf cart is included for groups of 4 or fewer, while reservations of 5 or more require a second golf cart. Golf carts are the primary means of transportation on North Captiva Island, and each cart is limited to 4 passengers. When our property caretaker discovered at arrival that the guest had brought 6 people instead of the 4 listed on the reservation and explained that the required second golf cart charge would apply, the guest objected and stated that she would leave us a negative review. This threat was made before she had even arrived at or experienced our home. We immediately offered the guest the option to cancel the reservation and receive a full refund if she did not wish to abide by the clearly disclosed terms of the booking. She declined that offer, chose to proceed with the stay, and later followed through with the negative review she had threatened before ever arriving at the property. We welcome honest feedback about a guest’s actual experience at our home. However, we will not waive clearly disclosed rules or fees because a guest threatens a negative review. Accurate guest counts and golf cart requirements apply equally to every reservation, and we stand firmly behind our decision to enforce those requirements in this case.

Thank you for the review! We're so happy to hear you enjoyed the island and our home. I'm glad our property manager was able to assist you so quickly regarding the flat tires on our golf cart. We've also emailed NCIC about the bicycles being unusable/unavailable, so they were made aware, and can address this issue. Thank you again for staying at Coconut Castaway!

Hi Troy - Thank you so much for the amazing review. We're happy to hear you and your family enjoyed your vacation on the island and that Coconut Castaway had a part in it! We'll also make sure to pass along your kind words to Tortuga as well. When you're ready to visit the island again, we hope you'll choose to stay at Coconut Castaway. We look forward to welcoming you back!

Thank you Maria! We're happy to hear you enjoyed your stay and look forward to hosting you again in the future!

Thank you for such a wonderful review! We always enjoy hosting you and look forward to another return in the future.