Slim pickings for our family of 5 spring trip. The cabin seemed pricey for area, but looked beautiful in pics.
The good: Counters, bathrooms and most floors appeared clean. Floors were real wood, which I appreciate. Appliances worked well. Mattresses were neither too firm nor too soft. A huge thing for me is good ac and the guest being able to operate it to their comfort level. While a house of that size could use dual units, it was around 80 while we were there and it mostly held up well. We had fun with the electronic dart board. There were plenty of games, but through likely no fault of owner and more so previous guests, several game pieces were missing. I don't really watch TV on vacation, but when TVs were on, they seemed to work well. I was able to get cell coverage with Tmobile inside, but not outside the cabin. The Internet was not as slow as I thought it would be based on previous reviews. We liked the signs with the Christian sayings throughout area near cabin. Kids got to see Amish people and their buggy for first time. I saw deer the first morning. Area felt safe.
The bad and the (other) buggy: The stink bug problem upstairs in terms of dead ones on the carpet and alive ones is an issue the owner needs to more adequately address. I reviewed the contract again before calling and saw that it implicitly states there are bugs in the woods, no credit would be given for bugs, so I felt there was no point in calling. Further, even if I did call, fumigating it and exposing us and more so, our kids to chemicals would not be an acceptable remedy. We just rearranged and made do. I did give Cindy feedback on this later and she did give a credit without me asking, which I appreciate. Hopefully, our situation was a random one and they'll have it under better control for future guests. The game machine Cindy said was broken after I asked if they all worked, was not there nor was it replaced with something else even though she said she planned to have it fixed before our arrival. Things like that should be figured into pricing. Bees were abundant, so we did not use hot tub. No headboard on master bed. Faulty bedroom fan. Grill dirty so didn't use. Exterior holes should be filled. Cold, leather couch instead of soft one in pics. No full/new roll of paper towels. 40 minutes from Hocking Hills.
We've rented many houses, mostly mountain cabins, so we've seen a lot, and all things considered, still believe this cabin deserves near 4 stars.