svg-sleeps svg-bedrooms svg-bathrooms svg-stay pets
Feedback

This property allows you to book online with a credit card. After submitting a reservation request, the owner or manager has 24 hours to accept, at which time your card will be charged and you will receive an email confirmation

Recent Old Town reviews

  • Second Home

    "When we first visited Key West we stayed at Poinciana Place and absolutely loved it,but we wanted to try the Seashell and 6 months later reserved it. When we got there Trevor and Sydney were just finishing putting the final touches together for us and after a quick lunch walked us through. It was everything we envisioned. The coziness of the cottage was matched only by its spaciousness. After a day at Fort Zach on the beach it was wonderful to come back and try the outdoor shower. The grill was perfect for brauts and later on the hottub was luxurious.. Especially with the different colored lights! When we felt like doing little it was very relaxing to just lounge in the living room with the shades open allowing the sun to come in or to sit on the porch swing and shoot the breeze with the local neighbors or hang out with their cat Mr. Gloria! Before we left we bought our customary Thank You card along with a couple of bottles of wine for our gracious hosts. We have always enjoyed your hospitality and we cannot wait until we come back again. The Seashell is perfectly located for quick access to Duval, Simonton, or Truman or to any of the quaint neighborhoods behind Whitmarsh... Which we took advantage of and toured. Thank You Carolyn for allowing us once again to share your home as if it were ours. We greatly appreciate it and you!"
    Guest: Vincent D. Date of Stay: August 2016 Review Submitted: September 15, 2016
    View listing
  • Stay like you live in Key West

    "Todd's home makes you feel like you are a native to Key West, walk and bike to all you need, come home to a comfortable well appointed place to hang out with the Family, is there anything better when traveling with your family or group of friends. While the weather wasn't the best given the winter of 2016, the house was wonderful. The pool was heated to a comfortable temperature allowing for swimming even with the cooler weather. The cottage with one bedroom was great for the parental units to retire earlier than the young adults. The front porch with rockers afforded the opportunity to watch the activities of Key West. Didn't want to leave, is there a better compliment?"
    Guest: Pamela24 Date of Stay: January 2016 Review Submitted: January 24, 2016
    View listing
  • Little piece of Heaven on Southard Street!

    "First time to Key West...won't be the last! The house was immaculate and decorated beautifully. Location was very central to everything. Several good restaurants are within a few blocks of the house. Loved being in a neighborhood where you really get the sense of what it would be like to live in Key West. The outdoor space was a real plus. Found ourselves out on the deck, morning, noon and evenings. Heated pool was a place to relax after a day at the beach, walking or sightseeing. Fun to stay in a house that has 120 years of history and imagine life back in the day!!! Owner was very pleasant to work with and was so helpful in answering questions and sharing recommendations. We had a great time!"
    Guest: Patricia S. Date of Stay: April 2016 Review Submitted: April 13, 2016
    View listing
  • The best of the best in Key West!

    "The perfect home for 4 people in so many ways! 2 Blocks from all the action on Duval Street. A secluded backyard with a heated pool, outdoor eating area & a couple of loungers. Inside is a beautifully decorated abode with soaring ceilings everywhere so it feels bigger than the conch home is actually. Just right & well afforded with luxury linens, overhead fans in all the right places & air conditioning. All the amenities you would think you have to bring to a rental, you really do not! Everything is there at your disposal. It is so nice you take pride in keeping it that way! Donald, the owner Sombra, the manager & neighbor Eddy are all so helpful. Anything you are interested in, they have a recommendation. Bike rental from Eaton Cycles was one of the recommendations. Our bikes were dropped off & picked up at no charge. As you read all the reviews for this home, just know that it has tender loving care in every corner the place. We hope to be back in the future! Thanks again for an exceptional week. Melissa & Greg, (Andy & Margie)."
    Guest: Melissa B. Date of Stay: November 2016 Review Submitted: November 21, 2016
    View listing
Sponsored Advertisement