Plus's - right on the water, totally flat, lots of water toys to borrow, two refrigerators, the deck is perfect, plenty of outlets and the A/C was awesome.
Minus - Can't really sleep more than 3 adults. Top bunk would only work for a small child due to ceiling height, bottom bunk futon is very uncomfortable, two of three of us couldn't unpack due to lack of dresser space, bare bones for blankets so I'd bring your own. Supplies were provided but in the smallest quantities. The door to the house has the deadbolt at eye level and the door handle at about mid shin. There is a major tripping hazard as you enter due to change in floor height that is hard to see. Not handicap accessible. Back door is sprung and will not lock at all.
It's a quirky place for sure. Our expectations when we travel are pretty low, so we made the best of it. They seem to be working the bugs out of catering to the vacation rental customer. I think they will get there.