The house was nicely warmed for our arrival. I used the screen door’s own stopper to keep the door open as I unloaded the car. About the second trip in, I noticed that top of the door was now falling off the top hinge. I managed to somehow hook it back up. Given the mild corrosion of the aluminum door, it was obvious the door has seen some years so I did not think twice about the issue. We enjoyed the coziness of the cabin. It’s smaller but has lots of character. The bedrooms are decent size but we all decided to sleep in the room with a queen and bunk bed. Good thing because one nap on the futon in the other room ended with a back ache. While the place is mostly in good shape I certainly spent time fixing it. I noticed back door shade had been pulled off the roller. I rolled it back up. The sink disposer had something left in it. I fished it out to prevent the disposer from breaking. The shower head fell off when my wife turned on the shower. I put it back on. BTW the shower head sprays limited water that is needle fine and actually hurts! One of the dining room chairs has ripped whicker backing. Get the picture here? The place is not new, needs some work, but has some character. After our departure I learned the owner is holding me responsible for the broken screen door. I get it; the owner thinks I broke it. I DID NOT. A quick search on Google will let anyone know the top hinge of any door is most vulnerable. Think about it: Older thin aluminum door + hundreds of open and closes over the years + loose screws on top hinge burrowing screw holes ever bigger = me holding the door and the bill? I don’t think that I should have to pay for a new door. I offered the owner $50 as this is an unfortunate situation for both of us. He is sticking to me paying for a brand new door ($100) and labor to install the door ($50) for a total of $150. The door was not new. Why do I have to pay anything? And if I pay something, why the full cost of the replacement?Final assessment: The place is a grandpa’s 1970’s musky cabin. It has some charm. The kitchen is clean. It’s a short walk to a great park for kids to play in. The couches are in need of a deep cleaning as they are pretty dusty. The bathroom shower head needs to be replaced. Things seem to be breaking down in the place which leads me to… I feel the owner is unreasonable. With the shape that this place is in, be careful or else you may be the next person literally paying to repair the next broken thing at this cabin.