Blandt de bedst anmeldte overnatningssteder i dette områdeBlandt de bedst anmeldte overnatningssteder i dette område
Højdepunkter
Plads til at brede sig
Nyd den rummelige indretning, der giver alle mere plads til afslapning.
Strandudstyr
Et sjældent fund – strandudstyret er klar til skønne dage ved havet.
Central beliggenhed
Du er aldrig langt fra din destination med denne praktiske beliggenhed.
4 soveværelser3+ badeværelserPlads til 8 personer
Populære faciliteter
Boblebad på stedet
Terrasse
Privat pool
Grill
Aircondition
Kæledyrsvenligt
Udforsk området
Palm Springs, CA
Palm Springs Air Museum
Place, Palm Springs Air Museum
4 min. kørsel
Ruth Hardy Park
Place, Ruth Hardy Park
6 min. kørsel
Palm Springs Convention Center
Place, Palm Springs Convention Center
8 min. kørsel
Palm Springs, CA (PSP-Palm Springs International)
Airport, Palm Springs, CA (PSP-Palm Springs International)
10 min. kørsel
Værelser og sovepladser
4 soveværelser (8 sovepladser)
Soveværelse 1
1 kingsize-seng
Soveværelse 2
2 sovesofaer (enkeltsenge)
Soveværelse 3
1 kingsize-seng
Soveværelse 4
2 dobbeltsenge
3 badeværelser, 1 toilet
Badeværelse 1
Sæbe · Håndklæder til rådighed · Toilet
Badeværelse 2
Sæbe · Håndklæder til rådighed · Badekar eller brusekabine · Badekar · Toilet · Kun brusekabine · Shampoo · Hårtørrer
Badeværelse 3
Sæbe · Håndklæder til rådighed · Badekar eller brusekabine · Toilet · Shampoo · Hårtørrer
Badeværelse 4
Sæbe · Håndklæder til rådighed · Badekar eller brusekabine · Toilet · Shampoo · Hårtørrer
Områder
Terrasse eller gårdhave
Køkken
Separat spiseområde
Have
Spiseområde
Om overnatningsstedet
Slap af i vores smukke og stilfulde svaneshus. Byen Palm Springs ID # 3607
Med en fantastisk udsigt over bjergene i San Jacinto har denne høje lofter smukke & stilfulde Palm Springs Salt Water pool / spa-hjem 4 soveværelser, 3. 5 badeværelser. 3 soveværelser har komplette badeværelser med eget bad. Stort åbent køkken med tilknyttet familieværelse; separat spiseplads og opholdsstue med pejs. Lukket indgangsplads og en 3-garage. Den ligger ud af soveværelset, der har direkte adgang til den mousserende pool og spa. En sovesofa i queensize-seng har plads til 2 børn under 12 år. Vi er en kort 10 minutters kørsel fra centrum af Palm Springs. Hvis du ikke har lyst til at køre, er Uber og Lyft de tjenester, som sandsynligvis bruges mest af gæster og lokale. Priserne varierer afhængigt af udbud og efterspørgsel. Hvis du ønsker, at poolen og spaen skal opvarmes, er der yderligere $ 49. 00 pr. Nat. Rygning forbudt. Ingen fester eller begivenheder Indtjekning er efter 15:00. Udtjekning er kl. 11. Mange tak for at overveje vores ejendom til dit ophold :) - Rygning er kun tilladt udenfor. Hele hjemmet, pool / spa, haver og en 3-garage med opbevaring om nødvendigt .. Vores ven og forretningsforbund, Roger, er din kontaktperson på stedet. Han er tilgængelig uanset hvad dine behov måtte være. Armando og Eduardo er også tilgængelige via telefon, tekst eller e-mail når som helst.
Tilføj datoer for priser
Lignende overnatningssteder
Classic '50s Home w/ a Private Pool, Spa, & Gas Grill - Close to Downtown
Deepwell Estates
Classic '50s Home w/ a Private Pool, Spa, & Gas Grill - Close to Downtown
Pursuant to the City of Palm Springs' Ordinance enacted in April of 2017, we are not allowed to have music outside at any time.
In addition, pursuant to the "Good neighbor policies" included in the ordinance, no noise is allowed outside after 10:00 p.m. We very much apologize.
We are allowed 4 cars overnight. Smoking is only allowed outside. Incidentally, our pool is not gated. We insist on strict supervision of children.
Vigtige oplysninger
Godt at vide
Overnatningsstedets nr.: 927034vb
Dette overnatningssted administreres af en privat vært (en person, der ikke udlejer som virksomhed eller erhverv). EUs forbrugerlov, herunder fortrydelsesret, gælder ikke for din reservation. Din reservation er dog dækket af din private værts afbestillingsregler.
Gebyrer for ekstra opredninger kan forekomme og varierer afhængigt af overnatningsstedets politik
Gyldigt billed-ID og kreditkort, debetkort eller kontant depositum kan være påkrævet ved indtjekning til dækning af påløbende udgifter
Særlige ønsker afhænger af tilgængelighed ved indtjekning og kan medføre ekstra gebyrer. Særlige ønsker kan ikke garanteres
Fester og events for grupper er strengt forbudt på stedet
Langvarige ophold godtages
Værten har angivet, at der er en kuliltealarm på overnatningsstedet
Værten har angivet, at der er en røgalarm på overnatningsstedet
Overnatningsstedets sikkerhedsforanstaltninger inkluderer brandslukker, førstehjælpskasse og lås med dødbolt
Dette overnatningssted har udendørsområder såsom altaner, balkoner eller terrasser, der muligvis ikke er egnede for børn. Hvis du har spørgsmål, anbefaler vi, at du kontakter overnatningsstedet inden ankomst for at bekræfte, at de har et passende værelse til dig
Om området
Palm Springs
Denne feriebolig befinder sig i Gene Autry – et område i Palm Springs, der ligger i bjergene. Palm Springs Convention Center og Palm Springs Swim Center er et par de lokale seværdigheder i området. Er du mere til shopping, kan du eventuelt kigge forbi Plaza de las Flores Shopping Center og Century Plaza Shopping Center. Ser du frem til et event eller en sportbegivenhed under din rejse? Se, hvad Agua Caliente Casino eller Big League Dreams Sports Park har på programmet.
Palm Springs Convention Center - 8 min. kørsel - 3.8 km
Palm Springs Besøgscenter - 9 min. kørsel - 5.2 km
Agua Caliente Casino - 9 min. kørsel - 4.2 km
Sådan kommer du rundt
Palm Springs Station - 17 min. kørsel
Palm Springs, CA (PSP-Palm Springs International) - 8 min. kørsel
Restauranter
Starbucks - 3 min. kørsel
McDonald's - 3 min. kørsel
Paul - 15 min. gang
Billy Reed's Restaurant Bakery & Bar - 4 min. kørsel
Taco Bell - 3 min. kørsel
Ofte stillede spørgsmål
Har Slap af i vores smukke og stilfulde svaneshus. Byen Palm Springs ID # 3607 en pool?
Ja, dette overnatningssted har en pool. Blandt pooltyperne finder du en opvarmet pool.
Hvad koster det at overnatte hos Slap af i vores smukke og stilfulde svaneshus. Byen Palm Springs ID # 3607?
Priserne for 1 nat for 2 voksne hos Slap af i vores smukke og stilfulde svaneshus. Byen Palm Springs ID # 3607 den 29. sep. 2026 starter fra 8.989 kr., inkl. skatter og gebyrer, fra og med den 21. sep. 2026. Denne pris er baseret på den laveste pris pr. nat fundet inden for de seneste 24 timer for ophold i de næste 30 dage. Priser kan til enhver tid ændres. Vælg dine datoer for mere præcise priser.
Er Slap af i vores smukke og stilfulde svaneshus. Byen Palm Springs ID # 3607 et kæledyrsvenligt overnatningssted?
Ja, kæledyr er tilladt på dette overnatningssted. Visse begrænsninger kan gælde. Kontakt overnatningsstedet for at få flere oplysninger.
Hvor meget koster parkering hos Slap af i vores smukke og stilfulde svaneshus. Byen Palm Springs ID # 3607?
Der er mulighed for parkering på overnatningsstedet.
Hvornår er indtjekning på Slap af i vores smukke og stilfulde svaneshus. Byen Palm Springs ID # 3607?
Indtjekning starter kl. 15.00.
Hvornår er udtjekning på Slap af i vores smukke og stilfulde svaneshus. Byen Palm Springs ID # 3607?
Udtjekning er kl. 11.00.
Hvor ligger Slap af i vores smukke og stilfulde svaneshus. Byen Palm Springs ID # 3607?
Dette feriested ligger i Gene Autry, kun 5 km fra Palm Springs Air Museum, Ruth Hardy Park og Palm Springs Dog Park. Derudover ligger Desert Regional Medical Center og San Jacinto-bjerget ca. 5 km derfra.
Anmeldelser
10
Enestående
Anmeldelser vises i kronologisk rækkefølge og har gennemgået en modificerings- og verificeringsproces, medmindre andet er angivet.
Bedømmelse på 10 − Fremragende. 37 af i alt 41 anmeldelser
10 - Fremragende
37
Bedømmelse på 8 − Udmærket. 4 af i alt 41 anmeldelser
8 - Udmærket
4
Bedømmelse på 6 − Okay. 0 af i alt 41 anmeldelser
6 - Okay
0
Bedømmelse på 4 − Dårligt. 0 af i alt 41 anmeldelser
4 - Dårligt
0
Bedømmelse på 2 − Forfærdeligt. 0 af i alt 41 anmeldelser
2 - Forfærdeligt
0
10/10
Rengøring
10/10
Indtjekning
10/10
Kommunikation
9,8/10
Området
10/10
Annoncens rigtighed
Anmeldelser
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Julie P.
15. maj 2026
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
The bedroom set up was perfect for us . The house was so spacious and the backyard and pool was great. Having the Property Manager there for check in and out was fantastic. Will rent this property again for sure .
Overnattede 3 nætter i maj 2026
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Philip L.
28. feb. 2026
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Great house .. very communicative host ! Enjoyed our stay !
Overnattede 4 nætter i februar 2026
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Brandee R.
7. mar. 2026
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
We had a great stay at the swan house. Very comfortable for our girls trip.
Overnattede 5 nætter i februar 2026
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Leticia G.
31. mar. 2026
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Wonderful house
Overnattede 3 nætter i marts 2026
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Gary M.
24. feb. 2026
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Everything was excellent. Wonderful home and gracious hosts.
Overnattede 6 nætter i februar 2026
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
ROSE D.
9. feb. 2026
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Absolutely amazing host and amazing property. We love everything about our stay and accommodations... the cleanliness,location and the host was perfect. Thank you for making out a stay unforgettable.
Overnattede 2 nætter i februar 2026
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Kelli D.
12. mar. 2026
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
This property was amazing! The beds were comfortable and everything was so clean and fresh. Backyard is like an oasis with beautiful Mountain View’s and watching the planes take off from the airport was so much fun to see. It has easy access to stores as well. This property is a 10!
Overnattede 2 nætter i marts 2026
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Chris K.
14. jan. 2026
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
The Swan House may just be our new fave house in Palm Springs! We stayed over the New Year's holiday and it was the perfect setup for two families. Loved that three bedrooms had en-suites, and the fourth bedroom with the daybed/trundle bed offers great flexibility. Kitchen was well stocked with all cooking essentials (not always a given), and had plenty of cabinet and counter space. We loved relaxing in the back yard, the mountain view makes for a great vibe. The pool heating and spa worked great, very easy controls - ditto for the propane fire pit table. And the owner Eduardo was a true pleasure to deal with - he was extremely pleasant and accommodating as a host. We'll def be back!
Overnattede 5 nætter i december 2025
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Nikki H.
30. maj 2025
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Wonderful Palm Springs escape
My friends and I had an amazing time at this house. There was plenty of space, it was clean and the kitchen was well stocked. The homeowners were so kind, so attentive and made sure we were well taken care of.
Overnattede 3 nætter i maj 2025
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Jacquelyn S.
24. apr. 2025
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Excellent Cozy Home away from home!
Stayed here for Coachella weekend! It was such a cute property, perfect location, with a pool and pet friendly. Took my two small dogs, and was plenty of space for the 4 of us adults! Can easily fit another 2-4 people! It was very clean, cozy, easy check-in/check out and host was very responsive with anything we needed! 10/10 would highly recommend and definitely stay here again.
Overnattede 2 nætter i april 2025
Verificeret anmeldelse
8/10 Godt
Karen D.
1. feb. 2023
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Palm Springs Stay
The property is very well maintained. We loved the house. Outdoor space was excellent.
Overnattede 5 nætter i januar 2023
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Emily R.
20. okt. 2024
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Super clean and beautiful home
Best stay ever. Beds are super comfortable. Home was very clean and beautiful. The owner was super accommodating to our needs. Thank you Eduardo and Armando, for sharing your home. We will definitely stay there again.
Overnattede 3 nætter i august 2024
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Charles S.
10. apr. 2025
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
nice quiet place
We received calls from manager/owner who was re-sponsive and wanted us to really enjoy our stay, whichwe did. We give 2 thumbs up for the pleasant contacts. Chuck and Carol and Family
Overnattede 7 nætter i marts 2025
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Ryan N.
5. jun. 2023
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Bachelorette Weekend
My friends and I had a blast here for my bachelorette weekend. Location was great, 5 minutes from town and 5 minutes from the airport. The house has a wonderful layout for a group and both indoor and outdoor spaces were perfect! The hosts were very generous and readily available if we needed anything at all! Would highly recommend this house, and will stay here for any future trips to Palm Springs!
Overnattede 3 nætter i juni 2023
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Heidi D.
12. dec. 2023
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Wonderful stay, and excellent hosts!
We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at this lovely Palm Springs home. The house was very spacious for our party of 7 and well-equipped. The grounds were well-kept, and it's situated centrally and in a nice neighborhood. Eduardo was the consumate host, who was very responsive to our inquiries and wanted to ensure a pleasant stay. The outdoor space was great, and we loved the view of the mountains. I wouldn't hesitate to stay there again, and recommend to others!
Overnattede 6 nætter i november 2023
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Julia M.
8. jan. 2024
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Fantastic Stay
Our party of 7 (3 kids aged 5 and under) had a great stay at this house! It was very spacious, clean, and well set up for our needs. The pool and spa were fantastic, we loved spending time swimming and relaxing. I have stayed in many houses in Palm Springs and would definitely return to this one. Host was very thoughtful and communicative! Thanks for everything.
Overnattede 4 nætter i januar 2024
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Brenda C.
9. jun. 2025
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Absolutely the best stay I have experienced. I have only great things to say about this wonderful home. Everything is like you see in the photos, but better! I had no idea how large the space was. The photos do not truly capture the space and the tranquility of his beautiful home. My family and I have such a lovely time. We felt comfortable, safe and enjoyed relaxing at the pool. The location is great, residential, but still close enough to the market. You will love staying here. Arturo, Armando and Eduardo were so attentive and helpful. We can't wait to go back.
Overnattede 2 nætter i juni 2025
Verificeret anmeldelse
8/10 Godt
diana v.
14. jan. 2025
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Palm Springs new year
Main drawback is that patio and pool face north -good for summer months but not good for the winter . House is spacious and well maintained .,owner was very responsive and helpful . Garden is not large .
Overnattede 5 nætter i december 2024
Svar fra VrboOwner den 13. mar. 2025
Hi Diana,
Thank you for your review. We just wanted to clarify that the garden is in deed large. The lot is 10,019 sq ft of which 2431 sq ft are of living space. Leaving 7,588 sq ft for gardens and pool. We do have a large garden. Even my 3 and a half years old son ask for permision to go out to the "Front park" : ) I know it is a matter of perception but the numbers are there.
Regarding the orientation of the pool, it is good for winter months but better in the summer. We haven't had any issue neither our guests for the last 9 years. Once again, It is a matter of percepcion.
Thank you Diana.
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Jeni A.
13. jul. 2024
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Loved loved loved it!!!!
This place was so relaxing. I would stay here again and again. The communication with the host was amazing, they got back to you right away. The house was an oasis of relaxation and peace. My kids were in the pool the whole week. We cooked everyday and my kids didn’t spend a lot of time on their tablets and cellphones. My teenagers actually played with my little ones. I will be back thanks for the amazing stay.
Overnattede 4 nætter i juli 2024
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Linda S.
7. feb. 2024
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
34th annual adventure
5 adults stayed for 8 days. The setup was perfect for our group. Having a private bathroom with each bedroom was great! The house is nicely decorated and there is plenty of room to be together as a group and also room to have separate spaces of our own. The location couldn’t be better for exploring Palm Springs and for some short day trips. We were there in the winter but were able to sit/dine outside unless it rained. The neighborhood was good for morning walks. Typically we like to visit a new place each year but we are talking about coming back here next year!!!
Overnattede 7 nætter i januar 2024
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Nicholle Z.
23. jul. 2024
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Spacious house for weekend with friends!
The house is comfortable and well-laid out for a weekend get-away with girl friends. It was well-appointed with linens, kitchen supplies, etc. and was immaculate; one bathroom had a minor mini-ant incursion that the host, Eduardo, immediately addressed even though it was after hours on Friday. Eduardo and his team are extremely responsive and welcoming. Before you check in, they send videos to help you navigate the basics, such as location of the garage lockbox, an extra communication that was helpful.
I highly recommend this property.
Overnattede 2 nætter i juli 2024
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Jill C.
3. jul. 2024
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Swan House Extraordinaire
Loved, loved, loved everything about this house, the hosts, and the on site manager. Our stay was fabulous! The pool was fabulous. The house was well equipped with everything. There were six adults, two teens, one preteen and a thirteen month old little boy in our party, and everyone was happy! Not an easy feat! One of us had to telecommute and the internet worked great, very fast. I wish we had booked our stay for more time. I highly recommend this house and plan on coming back much more often.A+++++++ from us. Thank you Armando, Eduardo, and Gabi🌻🌻🌻
Overnattede 2 nætter i juli 2024
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Cindy S.
31. dec. 2023
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Wonderful, spacious house!
Beautiful home! Three huge bedrooms, all with en-suite large bathrooms, plus another good-sized bedroom with a trundle bed, and a nice desk. Half bath in the hall is super convenient. We had three couples and two kids, and we had lots of room - very spacious home. Lots of room to spread out. Dining room was great for all 8 of us. Kitchen was nicely stocked with everything we needed. House was clean, and well-stocked with towels, blankets, pillows, etc. Full size laundry was great. The back yard was awesome - plenty of seating, chaise lounges, large dining table, a fire pit, and of course, the pool and spa (hot tub). The location is great - easy to get to downtown Palm Springs, the airport, and to highway 10. Eduardo and Armando were quick to answer any questions, and were very good hosts. We definitely will be back!
Overnattede 5 nætter i december 2023
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Carolyn G.
13. jul. 2024
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
Summer Getaway
The house is as described...fabulous! Every room is so large and fit the 6 of us so perfect. We spent a lot if tine at the house this year. It is angled so even though the temperature was high end of June, the breeze was so nice. We never got too warm and the pool was nice and cool. The kitchen is set up nice and we had most of our meals at the house. We did some BBQ. It is close to downtown by car, we took a ride there and stopped at a few shops. We plan to return when possible when the kids are out of school. The owners of the property are such wonderful, kind, caring people. They went out of their way to accomodate our needs and by conference call/text someone would be available at any time. The sweet housekeeper met us and showed us around/answered any questions. I cant think of anything that we didnt like. Thanks so much. We HIGHLY recommend this home for any length of stay.
Overnattede 2 nætter i juni 2024
Verificeret anmeldelse
10/10 Fremragende
Stacie S.
7. jul. 2023
Synes godt om: Rengøring, indtjekning, kommunikation, beliggenhed, annoncens rigtighed
A Serene Five-Star Retreat with Unbeatable Convenience at the Swan House!
My stay at Swan House in Palm Springs surpassed expectations! From the detailed attention (the owners called or texted everyday to make sure we were happy and comfortable) and exceptional hospitality of the owners, to Gaby's friendly and efficient tour, everything was perfect. Thoughtful inclusions like toothpaste and shower gel made us feel at home. The saltwater pool was an irresistible oasis, offering relaxation and magical experiences. The elegantly furnished bedrooms provided a serene haven, and cleanliness was remarkable throughout. The owners' exceptional accessibility, even while abroad, added a special touch. Conveniently located near downtown amenities, this rental is a gem. Highly recommended!
TLDR:
- Detailed attention and exceptional hospitality from the owners
- Friendly and efficient tour by Gaby (property manager)
- Thoughtful inclusions like toothpaste and shower gel
- Fully stocked kitchen including Tupperware, paper goods, and any pot, dish, serving, prep tools you could need
- Irresistible saltwater pool as an oasis for relaxation including towels, lounge chairs
- Serene and elegantly furnished bedrooms
- Remarkable cleanliness throughout the property
- sunken tub and oversized shower. Everyone had their own bathroom plus a guest restroom for entertaining.
- Owners' exceptional accessibility, even while abroad
- Convenient location near downtown amenities
- Highly recommended vacation rental at Swan House in Palm Springs
Book it!
Overnattede 3 nætter i juli 2023
Om værten
Vært: Eduardo Welter & Armando Rendon
Sprog:
engelsk, italiensk, spansk, portugisisk
Premium-vært
Værten sørger gang på gang for, at gæster får en god oplevelse.
Fortæl os, hvordan vi kan forbedre vores hjemmesideGiv feedback