I would describe the Gilbert Cottage as more of a camp or cabin than a cottage. While *cottage* suggests a cozy, thoughtfully appointed place to stay, this property felt entirely functional, with little aesthetic appeal or character.To be fair, I had seen the interior photos before booking and knew accommodations on Mount Desert Island are expensive. However, it was the accumulation of small disappointments that made the overall value feel lacking.The cottage was reasonably clean, and Mary, who prepared it, was wonderful—kind, accommodating, and conscientious. The issues were with the furnishings and maintenance. The bedding was old and uncomfortable, the furniture had inexpensive slipcovers, the curtains looked like the cheapest available, and the drip coffee maker looked like something from a discount store 25 years ago. The toilet seat, which had been held together with electrical tape, fell apart during our stay.The listing also includes photos of Acadia National Park labeled as the property's grounds. I'm familiar with the area, so I knew they weren't, but they should be labeled as nearby attractions instead.The wooded lot is peaceful and close to downtown Southwest Harbor, and we enjoyed coffee on the porch each morning. Overall, it worked as a place to sleep while exploring Acadia, but for the price, we expected more.