The location is excellent, the layout is great for 2 couples, the proximity of the restaurant is SO convenient, and the finishes make the place feel nice. However, the place needs some upkeep. The day we arrived, the kitchen sink clogged, the handle in one of the showers came off, one of the mini split AC units put out air that smelled intensely moldy, all of the AC units' filters were filthy...and later in the week, one of the showers clogged and one of the AC units completely stopped working. Basically, the place needs a maintenance refresh. Catalina was super nice and responded promptly, but the sink remained clogged, I had to get on chairs and wash the filters for the AC units, and there was a weird scenario in which the toaster, which worked perfectly for 2 or 3 days, stopped working. Neither my wife nor I could get the toaster to work--we're 40 and can use toasters--and when someone grabbed the toaster for a fix, we were sent a picture of bread being successfully turned into toast. Finally, the sliding glass doors are huge and let a lot of natural light get in, which is great, but opening and closing them is a workout: they're suoer heavy, and because the tracks they're on aren't greased at all, it's actually difficult to open and close them. And then they don't really lock. We were never worried, but still.
For the money, we liked it. But for the money, we should have loved it. And it would be easy to get it to that level. Just needs some upkeep.