This was our fourth time on Maui, but first time away from the big resorts. We loved it here and could easily have stayed another month. There is nothing fancy, but it was just what we wanted. Quiet, except for the sound of the waves. We ate all meals on the deck, grilled often, (fresh fish from the Fish Market Maui just down the street a couple miles). Enjoyed turtles, sunsets, and stars everyday and Mantas a couple of days.
The bed was very comfortable and a great shower. Although it is listed for four, I would definitely not do this with another couple (even kids would be difficult), but perfect for two. Kitchen was well supplied with dishes, pans, etc. but nothing besides salt and pepper, so buy your own olive oil, etc. if you plan to cook. There were a few housekeeping issues (no shampoo, no washcloths, no extra towels), but most resolved quickly.
The tiny beach accessed from the condo is underwater at high tide, but there is another small beach with public access just half a block away (or you can brave going around the rocks to get to it). Not a great place for kids, in my opinion. Access to the pool was extremely limited (COVID related, I think), but you could enjoy the grassy area right on the ocean all day long with owner provided chairs.
Would definitely return.