We had a great time!. The pictures/description were spot on. We were traveling with my spouse and myself, our two boys (1yo and 4yo) and our friends and their son who is 6mo.
The place was easy to find, instructions for everything were very clear. We settled in easily and got right to swimming. We ended up having the 4yo sleep in the master bedroom with us and our 1yo slept in a pack n' play that we brought in the room with just one bed. Then our friends and their 6mo slept in the room with two bed rooms. The house was good for babies (not a ton of knickknacks or places they could get hurt).
Our 4yo was obsessed with the loft area and would go up there to play whenever we were inside but when the afternoon sun hit the house, it could get pretty hot in the living room and then that sort of extended into the evening in the loft. There is a box fan (and plenty of fans around the house) but I'd recommend bringing another box fan if you want kids to sleep up there. They'd be fine without but just a pro tip.
The neighborhood is so amazing. Every house was built over 100 years ago and kept historically accurate - you literally feel like you're staying on Higgins Lake just as it was 100+ years ago. There are walking trails all around and we'd typically go on "a hike" with our kids once a day. Amazingly beautiful wooded neighborhood.
Our 4yo is a HUGE fan of bugs, dirt, fishing, swimming, fire pits, etc. He thanked us 5 times a day for bringing him to the cabin. It was the perfect place for him. We brought a little fishing pole, he caught some little fish off the end of the dock, we brought a minnow net and caught probably 100 minnows over the course of the week.
The water is really warm and probably about 4.5 feet for like 200 feet past the end of the doc (or more) - so it was warm, clear water that was easy for us all to hang out in. We brought an intertube with a bottom which turned out to be better for the two babies than those little floaty baby things because it was easier on our backs (since it's shallow) and the babies could splash in the bottom of the tube. Our 4yo used a puddle jumper and could touch easily in most places. So the water was perfect.
The house is nicely renovated inside but still has that great "cabin" vibe with all of the wood, fish over the fire place, and the firepit.
During COVID the dining hall is making meals for pickup instead of doing eat in. The food was good and they were BIG meals.