Se alla boenden
Lägenhet

Saint Germain des Prés - Takplattor - Eiffeltornet - Louvren - Notre Dame

Fotogalleri för Saint Germain des Prés - Takplattor - Eiffeltornet - Louvren - Notre Dame

Sjö
Marina
Sevärdhet
Boendeområde
Övrigt

Recensioner

9,8 av 10,
Enastående
2 sovrum2+ badrumSovplats för 4139.4 kvm

Populära bekvämligheter

  • Luftkonditionering
  • Grill
  • Eldstad
  • Tvättmaskin
  • Torktumlare
  • Kök

Utforska området

Map
Paris, Île-de-France
  • Louvren
    ‪6 min till fots‬
  • Notre-Dame
    ‪12 min till fots‬
  • Luxembourgträdgården
    ‪15 min till fots‬
  • Paris (CDG-Roissy-Charles de Gaulle)
    ‪35 min med bil‬

Rum och sängar

2 sovrum (sovplats för 4)

Sovrum 1

1 queensize-säng

Sovrum 2

1 queensize-säng

2 badrum, 1 toalett

Badrum 1

Bidé · Toalett · Endast dusch

Badrum 2

Toalett

Badrum 3

Badkar · Bidé · Toalett · Endast dusch

Ytterligare utrymmen

Däck eller uteplats
Kök
Balkong
Separat middagsplats
Matplats

Om boendet

Saint Germain des Prés - Takplattor - Eiffeltornet - Louvren - Notre Dame

Beläget i hjärtat av Uber-chic Saint Germain des Prés, erbjuder denna trippel lägenhet nära École des Beaux-Arts en unik smak av ett av Parijs mest historiska stadsdelar med panoramautsikt över hustaket från en privat terrass.

Lägenheten är inredd i en bekväm art deco-stil och består av ett vardagsrum / matsal, separat kök och toalett på ingångsnivån.

Lägenheten är helt luftkonditionerad på de tre nivåerna, vilket är extremt sällsynt i Paris.

Det finns 2 sovrum, ett på bottenvåningen med king size-säng och eget badrum inklusive en klo-foot badkar (med dusch över) och toalett, och en omklädningsrum / tvättstuga med tvättmaskin / torktumlare. Det andra vånings queen-sovrummet, som en gång kan användas som en konstnärs studio, erbjuder ett eget badrum med dusch och toalett. Detta sovrum ger på en privat terrass med fantastisk utsikt över hustaken i Paris till Eiffeltornet, Louvren, Notre-Dame och Sacré-Cœur-tornen. Den perfekta platsen att njuta av en kvällsdrink och titta på solnedgången över de stora monumenten i Light of Light.

De tre nivåerna i lägenheten är kopplade till en interiör antika trätrappa. Tillgång kan vara svårt för gäster med nedsatt rörlighet, så snälla överväga detta innan du bokar.

Kvarteret är genomsyrad av historia. Bara några steg ligger det berömda La Palette-kaféet, som vid slutet av förra seklet erbjöd begåvade unga konstnärer från de närbelägna Ecole des Beaux-Arts-måltiderna i utbyte mot målningar. Bland dessa konstnärer var Cézanne, Braque och Picasso. En av restaurangens två matsalar är klassad som ett historiskt monument och innehåller fortfarande berömda verk av konstnärer som äter där för mer än ett sekel sedan. Var någon av dem målade i lägenhetens studio? Den romantiska utsikten gör det lätt att tro att de kanske har varit ...

Fastighetsförvaltaren

Steven

Språk

Engelska, franska, tyska, italienska, polska, ryska och spanska
Lock

Skydda din betalning – boka alltid via Vrbo

Om någon ber dig att boka via dem eller betala dem direkt innan du bokar på Vrbo, ber vi dig att rapportera det.
Läs mer

Lägg till datum för priser

Bekvämligheter

Kök
Tvättmaskin
Torktumlare
Gratis wi-fi
Luftkonditionering
Uteplats

Liknande boenden

Vardagsrum

Elegans i Saint Germain des Prés - Bonaparte

  • Kök
  • Tvättmaskin
  • Torktumlare
  • Gratis wi-fi
9.8 av 10, (72 recensioner)
Elegans i Saint Germain des Prés - Bonaparte

Husregler

Incheckning efter 12.00
Utcheckning före 10.00
default

Barn

Endast vuxna
default

Evenemang

Inga evenemang tillåts
default

Husdjur

Inga husdjur tillåts
default

Rökning tillåten

Rökning förbjuden

Viktig information

Att hålla koll på

Detta boende drivs av en professionell värd. Att erbjuda boende är kopplat till värdens företagsverksamhet eller yrke.
Avgifter för extragäster kan tillkomma och varierar i enlighet med boendets policy.
Statligt utfärdad fotolegitimation och kreditkort, bankkort eller kontantdeposition kan krävas vid incheckning för oförutsedda utgifter.
Särskilda önskemål erbjuds i mån av tillgång vid incheckning och kan medföra ytterligare avgifter. Särskilda önskemål kan inte garanteras.
Fester och gruppevenemang är inte tillåtna på boendet.
Värden har angett att det finns en kolmonoxidvarnare på boendet.
Värden har angett att det finns en rökdetektor på boendet.
Det här boendet har utomhusområden såsom balkonger, uteplatser och terrasser som kanske inte är lämpliga för barn. Om du har frågor rekommenderar vi att du kontaktar boendet före ankomst för att bekräfta att de kan ta emot dig i ett lämpligt rum.
Boendets registreringsnummer 7510603358990

Bra att veta

Kontanttransaktioner på boendet får inte överstiga USD 1000, på grund av statliga bestämmelser. Du kan få mer information genom att kontakta boendet via kontaktuppgifterna i bokningsbekräftelsen.
Bil behövs inte för transport till och från detta boende.

Om området

Paris

Denna lägenhet ligger centralt i Paris. Notre-Dame och Opéra Garnier är viktiga sevärdheter, och för den som gillar att shoppa rekommenderas Champs-Élysées och Rue de Rivoli. Sugen på ett evenemang eller en match? Kolla upp vad som är på gång på Bercy Arena eller Roland Garros-stadion.
Karta
Paris, Île-de-France

I närheten

  • Louvren - 6 min till fots - 0.6 km
  • Notre-Dame - 12 min till fots - 1.0 km
  • Luxembourgträdgården - 15 min till fots - 1.3 km
  • Opéra Garnier - 6 min med bil - 2.4 km
  • Eiffeltornet - 9 min med bil - 3.9 km

Ta sig runt

  • Châtelet-Les Halles station – 15 minuters promenad
  • Mabillon Metro – 5 minuters promenad
  • Orly Airport (ORY) - 30 min med bil

Restauranger

  • ‪Restaurant Guy Savoy - ‬4 min till fots
  • ‪Café des Beaux Arts - ‬3 min till fots
  • ‪La Palette - ‬1 min till fots
  • ‪Le Nesle - ‬5 min till fots
  • ‪Kodawari Ramen (Yokochō) - ‬3 min till fots

Vanliga frågor och svar

Är Saint Germain des Prés - Takplattor - Eiffeltornet - Louvren - Notre Dame husdjursvänligt?

Nej, husdjur är inte tillåtna på boendet.

Vilka är incheckningstiderna för Saint Germain des Prés - Takplattor - Eiffeltornet - Louvren - Notre Dame?

Incheckning börjar 12.00.

Vilken utcheckningstid gäller för Saint Germain des Prés - Takplattor - Eiffeltornet - Louvren - Notre Dame?

Utcheckning sker senast klockan 10.00.

Var ligger Saint Germain des Prés - Takplattor - Eiffeltornet - Louvren - Notre Dame?

Denna lägenhet i Saint-Germain-des-Prés ligger tio minuters promenad från Seine, Louvren och Rue de Rivoli. Notre-Dame och Musee d'Orsay ligger också en kvarts promenad härifrån. Mabillon Metro ligger på 5 minuters gångavstånd och till Saint-Germain-des-Pres Metro promenerar du på 6 minuter.

Recensioner

9,8

Enastående

Recensioner visas i kronologisk ordning och har, om inget annat anges, genomgått en gransknings- och verifieringsprocess.
Läs merÖppnas i ett nytt fönster
10 - Fantastiskt i betyg. 24 av 27 recensioner
8 - Bra i betyg. 2 av 27 recensioner
6 - Okej i betyg. 0 av 27 recensioner
4 - Dåligt i betyg. 1 av 27 recensioner
2 - Väldigt dåligt i betyg. 0 av 27 recensioner

9,6/10

Renlighet

9,8/10

Incheckning

10/10

Kommunikation

10/10

Läge

9,6/10

Annonsens riktighet

Recensioner

10/10 Fantastiskt

Kimberly Brubaker B.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Wonderful stay in an amazing location

Truly loved the location of this property. The view from the upstairs bedroom and porch were remarkable. The kitchen is tiny but incredibly functional. The spiral staircases would be very difficult or impossible if the occupants had any mobility limitations. The furniture and upstairs mattress could be more comfortable. But access to that area is limited/difficult. Planning on going and staying here again. Property managers awesome!
Bodde här 32 nätter i april 2025

10/10 Fantastiskt

Tanya F.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Perfect in Paris

This apartment is fantastic! Great conventient location near multiple metro lines/central to tourism sites, plenty of grocers, cafes, bakeries within a short walk, and QUIET. I've never stayed in a city location so quiet. Very comfortable. AC!!
Bodde här 9 nätter i juli 2024

10/10 Fantastiskt

Eddie S.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

40th anniversary trip

We really enjoyed our stay at the apartment. The location was very convenient to everything we wanted to do, easily walkable to several locations and activities. The rooftop sitting area has incredible views across the city, including the Eiffel Tower. The apartment is classic French style and comfortable. The only challenge are the 2 tight spiral staircases leading up and down to the bedrooms. Couldn’t get our large suitcases up and down, but we managed. Overall a very nice property and experience.
Bodde här 10 nätter i september 2024

10/10 Fantastiskt

marty k., memphis

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Great location

Property manager and owner were terrific! AC worked fine during a very hot Paris week. Spiral staircase was a little tough but manageable.
Bodde här 6 nätter i september 2023

10/10 Fantastiskt

Ginny N.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Great Place!

From the top bedroom you can see the Eiffel Tower and Ferris wheel lit up at night. Very beautiful. Bed linens very nice. Space is large. Perfect for 4 people. Large bathrooms. Beautifully decorated. Great location close to everything. Aries checked us in and showed us how to work everything. Careful to make sure you are nimble enough to negotiate the spiral staircases especially with luggage.
Bodde här 4 nätter i oktober 2024

10/10 Fantastiskt

Richard E.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Cool in the latin quarter

Great views and great location Great Parisian neighborhood The A/C keep the apartment cool during the hot days, and the windows provided the perfect breeze at night
Bodde här 6 nätter i juni 2023

10/10 Fantastiskt

Terilyn C.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Amazing location and property

The property was beautiful and safe. The location was amazing- you can see almost everything from the rooftop terrace including the July 14th fireworks! It was a life saver to have air conditioning with the global heat wave that was happening this summer. You will not be disappointed with this property.
Bodde här 7 nätter i juli 2023

10/10 Fantastiskt

E A E.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Excellent location and views

This place is a true gem in the best Paris location to see many of the sites. Notre Dame, St. Chappelle, the Louvre, the Musee d'Orsay, Cluny Museum, all within walking distance. From the upstairs bedroom you can lie in bed and see the Eiffel Tower. There are narrow spiral staircases to get to each bedroom, but as long as you are not handicapped, or have knee issues, it is no problem. Love, love, love this place.
Bodde här 13 nätter i mars 2023

10/10 Fantastiskt

lisa h.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Lovely apartment

We love using VRBOs when we stay in Paris. This one was really nice. The only thing amiss was the downstairs shower was hard to adjust and the shower head sprayed all over. So we all used the upstairs shower. No biggie. Other than that, really lovely. Perfect location.
Bodde här 4 nätter i juni 2024

10/10 Fantastiskt

Kelli C.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Excellent Location. View of Eiffel Tower

Property was as expected based on photos and description. Charming with lovely views and walking distance to many museums and gardens. Temps were in the high 80s during our visit but careful use of the window shades and the 3 a/c units kept us comfortable (not ice cold like in the US, but definitely cool by European standards). Building was quiet and felt very safe and secure. Kitchen very small but well stocked. Oven, cooktop, coffeemaker, dishwasher, washing machine all worked well. This is an incredible location with a tiny grocery directly across the street and numerous cafes, shops, pharmacies, etc. within walking distance. Would happily stay here again and again.
Bodde här 4 nätter i juni 2023

10/10 Fantastiskt

Karen S.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Rooftop is a stunner!!

My friend and I spent 4 lovely days at this apartment-It was her first time in Paris and the rooftop terrace is amazing!! We had coffee up there and post dinner cocktails every day. Having 2 separate bathrooms (and a half bath!) is so hard to find—this was perfect. The bed linens and towels were all high quality and plentiful. The kitchen had a giant fridge for Europe and although we didn’t cook-this place would be great for a dinner party! Not going to lie-the spiral stairs up and down are tough-we just unpacked our suitcases on the main level and carried our clothes up/down. Easy enough. The neighborhood is also amazing! Steps from a little grocery and wine store. Wonderful cafes. Central to everything. Will definitely book this place again—if I am lucky enough!
Bodde här 4 nätter i mars 2024

10/10 Fantastiskt

Curt M.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Unique property in the Latin Quarter

WOW. What a great location. A few minutes to many great attractions and just 10 minutes to the Metro/RER for any others. The property is a classic French small apartment with tons of character. The spiral stair cases can be tricky to navigate, but they add to the experience. And, how about that terrace view! We spent every night on the terrace watching the lights come on the Eiffel Tower (with some beverages, of course). Where else in Paris can you sleep with a view of the Eiffel Tower from the bed?!?! There are TONS of cafes, bakeries and more nearby and a small grocery store where we stocked up on beer, wine, bread, cheese, etc. It is not fully of modern conveniences and space, but it's exactly what we wanted when visiting Paris. There was laundry and three small air conditioners that helped cool the apartment down when we got back each day. Just stay here and enjoy the ambiance of the left bank and the Latin quarter!
Bodde här 5 nätter i juni 2024

10/10 Fantastiskt

Valerie S.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Great apartment in central location

I stayed here with three friends for four nights. The apartment is roomy and well-appointed and is located in a great neighborhood within walking distance to lots of shops and restaurants as well as the Seine, Notre Dame and Saint Chapelle. A few things to know about the property... while it does have AC, it does not sufficiently cool during the day especially in the upstairs bedroom. We didn't care as we were out all day and at night we left the windows open which was wonderful, even though it was mid 80s during the day, it cooled off at night. The rooftop was magnificent. We spent morning coffee and evenings with wine up there and even watched the Eiffel Tower sparkling at 11pm one night. Amazing! The property has an elevator (three people max) but you still need to climb another flight of stairs to get to the apartment and the circular stairs in the apartment to the two bedroom are very narrow and challenging if you have a larger suitcase (we didn't so again, no problem for us). I highly recommend this property!
Bodde här 4 nätter i juni 2023

10/10 Fantastiskt

Dee G.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Wonderful location in the middle of Paris!

My husband and I and another couple stayed here for 9 nights to see the Christmas lights and Markets in Paris. This triplex served all our purposes as it has 2 full en-suite bathrooms and each of the bedrooms were private . The living/dining room was very comfortable and the whole place was decorated in Art Deco furnishings. The small kitchen was nicely appointed with 2 different coffee makers as well as other accoutrements. We really enjoyed our time here and got used to the wooden circular staircases. The piece de resistance was the terrasse on the roof where we enjoyed wine while watching the Eiffel Tower sparkle every night on the hour and you can also see Sacre Coeur, and the roofs of Beaux Arts and St Sulpice and St Germaine churches. Can’t wait to come back!!
Bodde här 9 nätter i december 2024

10/10 Fantastiskt

Kristin M.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Amazing

Bodde här 4 nätter i maj 2024

4/10 Dåligt

Carol P.

Gillade: Kommunikation och plats
Gillade inte: Renlighet och annonsens riktighet

Not as expected

This property was not as described on VRBO
Bodde här 6 nätter i september 2022

10/10 Fantastiskt

Paul H.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Very Nice..Just as Advertised

We (two 70ish couples) very much enjoyed our stay. Apartment was very well situated for touring both the Left Bank and crossing over to the Louvre, Marais, etc. Decent proximity to Metro. Unit is on fifth floor but there is a small elevator. As has been noted by others, the two bedrooms are located up and down from the main floor by a very tight winding staircase. Other than manipulating bags, we learned to deal with this but worth noting if stairs are an issue. Kitchen is also very small but it’s Paris and nearby nice restaurants were plentiful, especially a few blocks south to the St.Germain area. Rooftop terrace is as advertised…lovely either early morning or late evening. Stephan, who handled the check in process, met us downstairs and did a very good job of getting us set up in the apartment. Would definitely recommend to friends. PH
Bodde här 8 nätter i augusti 2022

10/10 Fantastiskt

Collin K.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Great place and great location

My family and I loved this property. It is located in a quaint neighborhood in St Germain but not far from great food and breakfast options as well as just across the river from the Louvre. The pictures don’t do the property justice, especially the upstairs bedroom and adjacent rooftop patio. We enjoyed having a glass of wine on the patio in the evening and loved watching the lights of the Eiffel Tower at 10 pm, 11 pm and midnight from our bed. The lower bedroom which our daughter enjoyed was very comfortable and the full bathroom was fantastic downstairs. The 2.5 bathrooms and air conditioning units on each floor made it very comfortable. We will happily recommend this to others and will stay here again!
Bodde här 8 nätter i augusti 2022

8/10 Bra

Michelle W.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation och plats

That view!

Location was great with about a 10-minute walk to the metro. The apartment was spacious with everything we needed and a view of the Eiffel Tower that did not disappoint. The downside was the WiFi did not work for the duration of our stay (it would connect but we could not access the Internet). Host might’ve been able to fix it but we were out of the apartment 10-12hrs/day and it was always too late to call by the time we returned and remembered it was an issue. We stayed at the height of summer so air conditioning was important to us. There is one large window unit that claims to cool the entire apartment. This is not really the case. The very top room was kept almost too cool, the middle living room was around 80°F and the bottom floor master bedroom was way too hot. Nevertheless, check-in was great, location was great, elevator (after 20,000 steps/day touring) was a lifesaver, and the apartment was spacious and clean. The beds were comfortable. Restaurants, grocery and the Seine all right nearby. We enjoyed our stay!
Bodde här 4 nätter i juli 2022

10/10 Fantastiskt

Edward M.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Sunrises and Fireworks

From the rooftop patio we saw the amazing July 13/14 fireworks from all over the City! And several very cloudy sunrises were truly fantastic! 103 and 106 degrees the last 2 days we were there. We were very comfortable because of the great air conditioning! And right in the vicinity of everything. Two weeks definitely not enough time to see it all. Terrible weather in July. So don't book July. That's our month.
Bodde här 13 nätter i juli 2022

10/10 Fantastiskt

Edward S.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

On the rue de Seine

The spiral staircase and views from the patio made it very special.
Bodde här 7 nätter i juni 2022

10/10 Fantastiskt

Doris B., New York, NY

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Rooftop Magic

This is a very special place, and while the photos are accurate, they can't begin to convey the actual experience of being on the top floor, higher than any of the surrounding buildings, with views of Paris-- rooftops, church spires, the Eiffel Tower-- all around. If you're there over a Sunday, get your coffee and listen to the church bells. Amazing. AND there's a dining table for 6 on the top floor patio! The layout of the apartment is perfect for 2 couples, with 2 spacious bedrooms and bathrooms (unusual for Paris apartments!) separated by the middle floor with living room/kitchen. Hosts are great-- I left something important behind and they went to the trouble of sending it by courier to our next stop. Thank you, Jean Francois! We'll be back!
Bodde här 4 nätter i juni 2022

10/10 Fantastiskt

Paul

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Absolutely Lovely!

We had a great stay! Two couples over 60, and friends for life. Perfect location! Walking distance to practically everywhere - the Louvre, the Arc…restaurants, shops…! Beds & pillows comfy, sheets super soft, bathrooms (each with a toilet) were clean and great size. The views from the upstairs bedroom and balcony were AMAZING! (Yes, you had to go through the bedroom to get to the balcony, not a problem for us). Watch the Tower light up each night at 10, 11, and midnight - breathtaking! Lots of antiques and Knick-knacks. If we had a complaint, which we don’t, it would be the kitchen - very tiny, but fairly well equipped, and you’re in Paris - eat out! There are a lot of stairs, a spiral staircase going up and one going down. You enter on the living area of the apartment, you have a flight of stairs to walk up from the lift. This is not child friendly, but you are told this in the write up. It just adds to the Paris experience. We would all stay here again in a heartbeat! Thank you so much for a wonderful place to call home in Paris!!!
Bodde här 5 nätter i maj 2022

10/10 Fantastiskt

Debra S.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Awesome Girls Trip

Great rental in a FABULOUS location. Can’t get more centrally located than this location. We were 2 moms with 2 recently graduated from college daughters wanting to explore Paris for a week. This apartment was 3 levels and had 2 separate bedrooms, each located on the lower level and upper levels, and had the living room/dining room/kitchen on the middle level. Each bedroom had its own bathroom with great water pressure (esp for Europe). Plenty of towels and extra sheets. We only needed the A/c on day 1 and was typical A/c for Europe-cooling off the area a “bit.” We opened the many windows every night and was perfect sleeping weather. I do imagine the top bedroom would be very warm in the summer with the sun baking on it all day, even with A/c, but the views from that bedroom are amazing. The roof top patio was by far the BEST part of the apartment. From the patio, you can see the Eiffel Tower (Great for nighttime pictures), the Louvre, Norte Dame Bell Towers, and so many other things. The only negative was the very narrow circular staircases you needed to go up and down to get to the other levels of the apartment. Even our 22 year olds walked slowly and hung on to the rail. No issues for us, but elder people might have serious issues navigating this. Also to be noted that the building is very secure…one code and a separate key to enter. We always felt safe. I would recommend staying here and would definitely stay here again myself! Owners/managers were very responsive!
Bodde här 6 nätter i maj 2022

8/10 Bra

Verifierad resenär

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Perfect Location

Just returned from 4 nights in Paris and the location of the property was perfect! Wonderful terrace with incredible views. This is a large property by Paris standards with 2 1/2 baths. The spiral stairs are narrow and would be difficult for those with mobility issues. The kitchen is small but functional. The top floor gets very hot during the day. The listing says the property has air conditioning however at check in we were told there is no air conditioning. This was not a problem at night as temps we’re cooler in the evening. Overall great stay and would rent again
Bodde här 4 nätter i maj 2022

Om värden

Steven är värd

Värdens profilbild

Vad som gör detta boende unikt

A unique experience of Paris for a select few....

Språk:

Engelska, Franska, Tyska, Italienska, Spanska, Ryska, Polska
Har du några förslag på hur vi kan förbättra sidan?Ge feedback