Hel semesterbostad·Privat vÀrd

New York City Vacation home Waterfront with Sunsets over Manhatan

Semesterboende vid vattnet med kök och balkong

Fotogalleri för New York City Vacation home Waterfront with Sunsets over Manhatan

Exteriör
Terrass/Patio
Interiör
Marina
Planlösning

Recensioner

9,4 av 10,
EnastÄende
3 sovrum3 badrumSovplats för 8102.2 kvm

PopulÀra bekvÀmligheter

  • Torktumlare
  • Kök
  • TvĂ€ttmaskin
  • Jacuzzi
  • Grill
  • Uteplats

Utforska omrÄdet

Se pÄ karta
New York, NY
  • Place, Jamaica Bay
    â€Ș1 min till fots‬
  • Place, Gateway National Recreation Area
    â€Ș1 min till fots‬
  • Place, East Jamaica Bay Islands
    â€Ș6 min till fots‬
  • Airport, New York, New York (JFK-John F. Kennedy Intl.)
    â€Ș19 min med bil‬

Rum och sÀngar

3 sovrum (sovplats för 8)

Sovrum

1 queensize-sÀng

Sovrum

+2
4 enkelsÀngar, 1 futon (dubbel) och 1 queensize-sÀng

Sovrum

1 queensize-sÀng

3 badrum

Badrum

TvÄl · Handdukar tillhandahÄlles · Badkar · Toalett · Endast dusch · HÄrtork

Badrum

TvÄl · Handdukar tillhandahÄlles · Toalett

Badrum

Handdukar tillhandahÄlles · Toalett · Endast dusch · HÄrtork

Ytterligare utrymmen

Terrass eller lanai
Kök
Balkong
Lekplats utomhus
TrÀdgÄrd
Matplats

Om boendet

New York City Vacation home Waterfront with Sunsets over Manhatan

This New York City Vacation Rental is a 3 bedroom waterfront house with 2 full baths and a 1/2 bath on 1st floor. It is a five block walk to New York City’s mass transit system. The train to downtown Manhattan is an approximately 45 minute ride.The house is located on Jamaica Bay in Broad Channel, Queens. Here guests will enjoy beautiful views of the Manhattan skyline and breathtaking sunsets. Guests will benefit from this ideal location. Not only will guests have the benefit of being a short ride away from New York City one of the world’s greatest cities, they will also take pleasure in the beautiful peaceful surroundings of Broad Channel and Rockaway. These neighborhoods are ideal for boating, fishing, swimming, surfing, bird watching or walks along the beach.



Broad Channel is just 20 minutes from Kennedy Airport & a 45 min subway ride to downtown New York City
Located in the heart of a Gateway National Park, with it's visitor center a short walk away.
Jamaica Bay Wildlife Refuge, part of Gateway National Recreation Area, is one of the largest bird sanctuaries in the northeastern United States (over 9,000 acres).

Jamaica Bay is the best place in New York City to observe seasonal migration of birds. The Bay's islands and their ponds are a key layover spot for birds along the Atlantic Flyway. During the spring and late summer, it's possible to see over a hundred types of birds, including the wonderfully named Lesser Yellow legs.

This neighborhood consists of single family homes, public parks which include with handball and tennis courts. Small boats can be rented at a local fishing station within walking distance

LÀgg till datum för priser

BekvÀmligheter

Jacuzzi
Kök
TvÀttmaskin
Torktumlare
Luftkonditionering
Uteplats

Liknande boenden

Husregler

Incheckning efter 15.00
LÀgsta Älder för att hyra: 21 Är
Utcheckning före 10.00
default

Barn

Barn tillĂ„ts: 0–17 Ă„r
default

Evenemang

Inga evenemang tillÄts
default

Husdjur

Inga husdjur tillÄts
default

Rökning tillÄten

Rökning förbjuden

Utcheckningsinstruktioner

VÀrden krÀver att du gör följande innan du checkar ut:
Starta diskmaskinen.
Samla ihop personliga föremÄl.
SlÀck lamporna, lÄs dörrarna och lÀmna tillbaka nycklarna.
Om dessa inte genomförs kan det leda till ett negativt omdöme frÄn vÀrden.

Viktig information

Att hÄlla koll pÄ

Detta boende drivs av en privat vÀrd (nÄgon som inte agerar inom sin företagsverksamhet eller sitt yrke). EU:s konsumentlagar, inklusive ÄngerrÀtten, gÀller inte för din bokning. Din bokning omfattas av den privata vÀrdens avbokningspolicy.
Avgifter för extragÀster kan tillkomma och varierar i enlighet med boendets policy.
Statligt utfÀrdad fotolegitimation och kreditkort, bankkort eller kontantdeposition kan krÀvas vid incheckning för oförutsedda utgifter.
SÀrskilda önskemÄl erbjuds i mÄn av tillgÄng vid incheckning och kan medföra ytterligare avgifter. SÀrskilda önskemÄl kan inte garanteras.
Fester och gruppevenemang Àr inte tillÄtna pÄ boendet.
LÄngtidsuthyrning Àr möjlig.
Detta boende anvÀnder miljövÀnliga rengöringsprodukter.
VÀrden har angett att det finns en kolmonoxidvarnare pÄ boendet.
VÀrden har angett att det finns en rökdetektor pÄ boendet.
PÄ detta boende finns bland annat följande sÀkerhetsdetaljer: brandslÀckare och instickslÄs.

Bra att veta

Bil behövs inte för transport till och frÄn detta boende.

Om omrÄdet

Far Rockaway

Denna semesterbostad ligger vid vattnet i Broad Channel, en stadsdel i Far Rockaway. Brooklyn Bridge Àr en viktig sevÀrdhet, och vackra naturupplevelser kan du fÄ i omrÄdet kring Flushing Meadows-Corona Park och Battery Park. Sugen pÄ ett evenemang eller en match? Kolla upp vad som Àr pÄ gÄng pÄ Barclays Center Brooklyn eller UBS Arena. Upplev vattenÀventyr som vattenskidÄkning och windsurfing i nÀrheten, eller prova pÄ andra friluftsaktiviteter som cykling och ridning.
Karta
New York, NY

I nÀrheten

  • Jamaica Bay - 1 min till fots - 0.0 km
  • Gateway National Recreation Area - 1 min till fots - 0.0 km
  • East Jamaica Bay Islands - 6 min till fots - 0.6 km
  • West Jamaica Bay Islands - 11 min med bil - 2.8 km
  • Times Square - 40 min med bil - 37.7 km

Ta sig runt

  • Inwood Station – 10 min med bil
  • Broad Channel Station – 9 minuters promenad
  • John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK) - 22 min med bil

Restauranger

  • â€ȘDunkin' - ‬4 min med bil
  • â€ȘMcDonald's - ‬4 min med bil
  • â€Ș301 Chinese Resturant - ‬4 min med bil
  • â€ȘPopeyes Louisiana Kitchen - ‬5 min med bil
  • â€ȘRockaway Beach Bakery - ‬4 min med bil

Vanliga frÄgor och svar

Är New York City Vacation home Waterfront with Sunsets over Manhatan husdjursvĂ€nligt?

Nej, husdjur Àr inte tillÄtna pÄ boendet.

Hur mycket kostar det att parkera vid New York City Vacation home Waterfront with Sunsets over Manhatan?

Parkering Àr tillgÀnglig pÄ boendet.

Vilka Àr incheckningstiderna för New York City Vacation home Waterfront with Sunsets over Manhatan?

Incheckning börjar 15.00.

Vilken utcheckningstid gÀller för New York City Vacation home Waterfront with Sunsets over Manhatan?

Utcheckning sker senast klockan 10.00.

Var ligger New York City Vacation home Waterfront with Sunsets over Manhatan?

Detta familjevÀnliga semesterboende vid vattnet ligger mindre Àn 15 km frÄn Aqueduct Racetrack, Five Towns Shopping Center och Marine Park Golf Course. Resorts World Casino och Aviator Sports and Events Center ligger ocksÄ mindre Àn 15 km hÀrifrÄn. Broad Channel Station ligger pÄ 9 minuters gÄngavstÄnd.

Recensioner

9,4

EnastÄende

Recensioner visas i kronologisk ordning och har, om inget annat anges, genomgÄtt en gransknings- och verifieringsprocess.
LĂ€s merÖppnas i ett nytt fönster
10 - Fantastiskt i betyg. 34 av 44 recensioner
8 - Bra i betyg. 8 av 44 recensioner
6 - Okej i betyg. 0 av 44 recensioner
4 - DÄligt i betyg. 0 av 44 recensioner
2 - VÀldigt dÄligt i betyg. 2 av 44 recensioner

8,8/10

Renlighet

10/10

Incheckning

9,8/10

Kommunikation

9,6/10

LĂ€ge

9,4/10

Annonsens riktighet

Recensioner

8/10 Bra

Guy M.

Gillade: Incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Great Location

The house is in a great location with great views of the city from a peaceful area. The listing was accurately described and the owner was great to deal with. The furnishings could use some updating and some TLC. The owner was very responsive and took care of everything immediately the two times we had to call him.
Bodde hÀr 8 nÀtter i maj 2021

8/10 Bra

Eugene B.

Gillade: Incheckning, kommunikation och plats

It was quiet and relaxing

It was quiet

10/10 UtmÀrkt

Patricia G.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

All about the view.

Nice property with tons of space for my small family. It will fit 2 families with 2 kids each easily.
Bodde hÀr 2 nÀtter i september 2020

10/10 UtmÀrkt

Thomas H.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Christmas

Had a wonderful time at the property. We enjoyed being able to relax in a home environment while visiting family for Christmas.

10/10 UtmÀrkt

Natalie A.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Best vacation yet!!

We are a family of 9 and vacation every year around Christmas. The house was more than enough space for all of us to Vacation comfortably. I don’t think that we could’ve gotten a better location, easy travel via subway to manhattan, easy travel via car to Long Island. The view is more beautiful than I imagined it could be. The neighborhood is quiet and safe. Pizza from Tommy’s a short walk away was the best pizza I ever had! Michael is so responsive and very accommodating. I would recommend this property to all of my friends and family. It was such an enjoyable experience and vacation. Thank you Michael for everything!
Bodde hÀr 8 nÀtter i december 2019

8/10 Bra

Myrna H.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

good holiday

We really enjoyed our stay Surrounding could have been a bit more up-keep The house was fine with a few hick-ups which we fixed ourselves where possible and we had great assistance from Michael. However, he seemed to think there was damaged to his countertop by us. For the record we meet the damaged and it was covered over with a glass filled with tea bags Otherwise we enjoyed our stay and took very good are of the house I think the furnishings in the living room need upgrade and in darker colours

10/10 UtmÀrkt

TERI B., Smartsville, CA

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

great stay

The house was awesome, we really enjoyed our stay, the only concern we had was the high tide that flooded us in, we were unaware of this.
Bodde hÀr 7 nÀtter i oktober 2019

10/10 UtmÀrkt

Iulia S.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Nice location by the ocean

The house is right by the ocean, communication with Michael went smoothly, he was able to answer all out questions and was very friendly and wanted to make us feel welcomed. The area is safe and there is not much traffic, so it is also quiet. The sunset over Manhattan is amazing! The connection with the rest of the city is pretty ok, there is the A line which takes you directly to Manhattan. There is also a bus which goes to the beach and Queens. I would recommend this place if you are looking for a quiet place (we were travelling with a 2-year-old) but you also want to do some sightseeing.
Bodde hÀr 7 nÀtter i augusti 2019

10/10 UtmÀrkt

Kelly R.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Perfect

Michael and his family were so kind! It was perfect for us. My teenagers by the end of our trip were taking the train/subway in an out of the city on their own and had the best time.
Bodde hÀr 4 nÀtter i augusti 2019

10/10 UtmÀrkt

Nicole B.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

A gem!

Looking to visit NYC but don’t relish the thought of sleeping in a concrete jungle? Broad Channel is a small beach town within the metropolis of NYC. This house is right on the water and every night we savoured watching the sunset over the skyscrapers of NYC. It was like we were living in a postcard. Our host Mike was friendly, easy to message and his home had all the space and amenities we needed. Do yourself a favour and go the less traditional NYC vacation route...forget an overpriced standard hotel,room in Times Square. Stay somewhere where you can sleep with the windows open, have space to recharge and sea air to breathe. 5stars!
Bodde hÀr 7 nÀtter i juli 2019

8/10 Bra

Lynette S., Loveland, OH

Gillade: Incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

We loved the location but we went during the crazy heat wave of 2019

The view was incredible and we loved watching the wildlife from our rooms and the back deck. There was great neighbors and even the property owner's (that share the building) family and friends were super nice. Michael's wife was very nice and welcoming yet Michael wasn't that way once we asked for a fan. The house was a bit run down and there was electrical things that were a little sketchy. There was a broken light hanging from wires in the hall, the fan in the bedroom wasn't working. We asked Michael if there was a box fan to use and he wanted to see it for himself the broken fan. So they walked upstairs to look at it and he let us borrow the box fan. All the upstairs outlets weren't working except in the bathroom but we didn't tell him because we felt it couldn't be fixed while we were there and that we were already an imposition on him because we asked to use the washer 2x during our 4 night stay at their house during our 2 week vacation. Normally we wouldn't wash our clothes 2x at a house but we were there during the crazy heat wave that hit the East Coast and the real feel temp in NYC was 123°F!! So our clothes were sweaty and stinky and there was 2 families (8 total) and we did a total of 4 washes during the 4 nights. There was little things like no wash cloths, dish soap, hand soap in the 2 bathrooms, oven mits, or baking sheets (we were reheating our delicious NY style pizza that was just up the street). When we first got to the house the inside was 90°F, so it didn't seem inviting from the first impression. It took a long time for it to cool down even with the windows open letting in the cross winds, which was advised to do, but again it was in the high 90's outside. We liked the location but don't think we'd come back. We felt like we were an imposition and the electrical issues, especially with a lot not working, just made it feel like he didn't care enough to take care of this potential gem of a house.
Bodde hÀr 4 nÀtter i juli 2019

10/10 UtmÀrkt

Joshua G.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Clean and safe

The house was a great investment for our NYC trip. The location is safe and the view of Manhattan is beautiful at sun set. Would definitely recommend this place. A+++
Bodde hÀr 5 nÀtter i juni 2019

10/10 UtmÀrkt

Timothy K.

Gillade: Renlighet, incheckning, kommunikation, plats och annonsens riktighet

Perfect location

Overall me and my family had a wonderful time on our vacation. The house was exactly what we needed. The views were awesome and I couldn’t be happier with our overall stay.

10/10 UtmÀrkt

Kenneth H., Lisbon, Maine

Excellent Views, Peaceful Setting, Perfect Size for Family of 5 or 6.

My family & I spent a week here this May. The house made an excellent "home base" for our vacation. It is an easy walk to the subway station and then you can take the train anywhere you want to go. The house had all of the necessities as well as plenty of towels and a large assortment of cookies utensils. Be aware of the tolls in the area ($4.75 to drive on or off of the island each time as well as $9.50 at Whitestone or the Bronx bridge). The owner was easy to work with. If we vacation in the area again, we will absolutely consider staying here.
Bodde hÀr 7 nÀtter i maj 2019

10/10 UtmÀrkt

Mike L., Houston Texas

A great place to stay

Loved the place, it was perfect for the family. We had 10 guests the first night, and 9 guests after that. Steve the next door neighbor was super nice to visit with. The house was clean and had everything we needed. If you want a nice relaxing place to go that is outside the city this is the place. The porch overlooking the bay with the city in the background was perfect, the weather was also perfect. There was a train station close by that got us everywhere where we wanted to go. We did rent cars and did some driving to Coney island and such but I would not recommend driving in NY. Yuck!!! Mass transit is the only way to go esp if you don't know the city. Thank you Michael.
Bodde hÀr 3 nÀtter i maj 2019

10/10 UtmÀrkt

Eddie C.

Family Get Together

We were getting together to celebrate my daughter's graduation from Hofstra University. We were 8 strong and the Sunday even dinner had 16 attendees and we had plenty of space with great commute time to everything.

10/10 UtmÀrkt

Gayle K.

Perfect house for our vacation

The house was wonderful, central for all places we wanted to visit. The view OUTSTANDING. The owner was terrific, made us feel so welcome and any question we had, he replied to us quickly. The train station a few blocks away from us was so convenient. The deli and ice cream store, one block away were great. Growing up in NY and missing the delicious food was easily remedied by ordering from the deli. The sandwiches and hot food was spot on. The house has 3 bathrooms, 2 of them with a shower, tub or both, which made getting ready to start our day easier for the 5 of us. The kitchen was well stocked with dishes, glassware, pots, pans. There are some condiments in the pantry and we happily left some that we purchased. Plenty of towels, beds were comfortable. There is a washer/dryer in the house but not readily accessible. I contacted the owner and he arranged the day for us to use them. The house has 2 sides and the laundry room shared by both parties. It was no problem at all, and I understand completely how people can and do take advantage, so arranging with the owner was the right thing to do. Every morning I started out having coffee on the deck, and every night relaxed on the deck taking in the NYC skyline and the gorgeous sunsets. My grandchildren had plenty of space to run around on the property and check out the fish, crabs seagulls and swans in the water.My granddaughter slept in the room on the 3rd floor, and loved looking out of the window seeing the water and the skyline. Easy access to parking off the street which was most helpful. When I visit my family in N.Y. again, I will plan my vacation on the dates available at this home. We had a fabulous vacation and this home and the owner played an important role in the successful stay.
Bodde hÀr 8 nÀtter i juli 2018

8/10 Bra

Maribel M., Dallas

It was great view spacious compared to hotels

I would stay there again
Bodde hÀr 4 nÀtter i maj 2018
Recensionen skickades in före 2018 och har inte verifierats.

10/10 UtmÀrkt

Carol R.

Great place for our College Reunion!

Nice home! Well kept! Plenty of room for the 6 of us. Best feature was the view of Manhattan! We would definitely go back!
Recensionen skickades in före 2018 och har inte verifierats.

2/10 VÀldigt dÄligt

Sylvia F.

Nach 7 Jahren wieder hier

Wir waren vor 7 Jahren schon einmal da der Vermieter ist sehr nett an dem Ferienhaus hat sich seither nichts mehr verÀndert was wir eher schade fanden da die Möbel schon etwas abgewohnt und fleckig sind. Es fehlte auch etwas Sauberkeit und Liebe zum Detail Preis Leistung passt hier leider nicht mehr. Eine Reise ist New York jedoch immer wert.
Bodde hÀr 6 nÀtter i december 2016
Recensionen skickades in före 2018 och har inte verifierats.

8/10 Bra

Frank B.

Ruhe und einen schönen Ausblick

Wir waren vom 22.10 bis 27.10.16 in diesem Ferienhaus. Ich hatte beim Vermieter die ca. Ankunftszeit angegeben, die wir auch eingehalten haben, es war aber Niemand vor Ort. Über die Handynr. war Er auch nicht erreichbar. Zum GlĂŒck war noch eine NiederlĂ€ndische Familie in der anderen HaushĂ€lfte, von der wir die Festnetznr. erhielten. So konnten wir noch an diesem Abend einziehen. Ansonsten ist alles wie in der Beschreibung angegeben und Sauber. Bei einem Ferienhaus ist die Ausstattung an HandtĂŒchern und BettwĂ€sche, natĂŒrlich nicht mit einem Hotel vergleichbar. Aber man kann ja ein Kopfkissenbezug und ein Badetuch mitbringen und ist auf der sicheren Seite. Die Möbel sind ein bischen in die Jahre gekommen, ansonsten WLAN, Radio und Fernseher sind vorhanden. Der Ausblick von der Hausterasse auf die Skyline von New York ist etwas besonderes. In der Straße ist es sehr ruhig, zumindest im Herbst. Vom Ferienhaus bis zur U Bahn Station A, sind es nur ein paar Fussminuten. Einkaufsmöglichkeiten fĂŒr Lebensmittel auch nur 300 Meter entfernt. Wer wie wir mit dem Mietwagen da ist, sollte natĂŒrlich Long Beach und Rockaway Beach besuchen, man muss dafĂŒr MautgebĂŒhren bezahlen,hin und zurĂŒck 8 $. Broad Channel ist vom JFK und von Manhatten aus, sehr gut zu befahren auf dem Weg dorthin sind auch zahlreiche Restaurants, der Howard Beach Blv. Ist schon rechtzeitig ĂŒberall ausgeschildert, der nach Braod Channel und spĂ€ter nach Rockaway fĂŒhrt. Trotzdem empfiehlt sich fĂŒr NY ein Navisystem.. Einkaufstipp von uns ist der Key Food Markt auf dem Howard Beach Blv. In Richtung Rockaway. Nicht gerade billig aber eine erstaunliche Auswahl an Lebensmitteln. Restaurant Tips, auf alle FĂ€lle das Cross Bay Diner. Mit einer riesigen Auswahl an Speisen, Sauber, Super freundliche Bedienung und wechselnden MenĂŒ Angeboten. Zum anderen das Belle Harbor Steakhouse in Rockaway, mit Guten Seafood Angeboten. Kann man auch mit der U Bahn erreichen, liegt 150 m , von der Endstation Linie A. Wir haben an unserem Abreisetag bis 12 Uhr gewartet, aber es kam Niemand zur Abnahme, so das wir die SchlĂŒssel im Haus ließen.
Bodde hÀr 5 nÀtter i oktober 2016
Recensionen skickades in före 2018 och har inte verifierats.

10/10 UtmÀrkt

Melissa P.

Great Place to Stay

We were a group of three adults and five kids ages 12 and 13 years old from DC and Boston, meeting in the middle. This was the perfect house for us. There were enough bathrooms (one on each of the three floors) and enough space to stretch out. Broad Channel is a small, quiet place that looks like a fishing village. The kids went out on the deck, dock, and walked around town. They went to the nearby school yard, bought a pizza at a shop nearby, got to know a cat who was wandering around, and found "treasures" on the curbs as they walked through town. It is a world away from the hustle and bustle of Manhattan. The view from the deck was beautiful, and there was a big table and chairs out there where we could eat and admire the view. There was no problem with airport noise when we were there. The beds were comfortable. There was parking right beside the house. When we went into Manhattan, we used the subway. It was raining that day, so we drove to the subway stop and easily found a parking spot there. It's a short drive to Rockaway Beach. Michael and his family were very responsive and accommodating. If you want to visit the city and get away from it, too, stay here. We would stay here again.
Recensionen skickades in före 2018 och har inte verifierats.

8/10 Bra

Chris N.

comfortable stay away from the city

the space was just right for us; plenty of room and the extra bathrooms were perfect. The location is just far enough from the city to still be in the city but away from the hustle and bustle. It's a short walk to the train/subway and a block from the mini market.
Recensionen skickades in före 2018 och har inte verifierats.

10/10 UtmÀrkt

Bettina W.

Very nice place to stay

To stay in this house was a very good decision as we could combine city tours in NYC (easy access to metro going straight downtown) and still come back after an exhausting day to a peaceful home. The view from the bedrooms is incredible and good weather allows you to enjoy the skyline of NYC sitting on the balcony. There is a park not to far away where one can go for a walk or a run. The owner provided very good customer service. It was mostly clean in the house and there were all things necessary for cooking available. Conclusively, it met our expectations and we enjoy to come back one time. We would definitely recommend this property.
Recensionen skickades in före 2018 och har inte verifierats.

10/10 UtmÀrkt

Denise T.

New York Waterfront

We had a fantastic time staying in this wonderful house, the views of NYC were amazing. All 6 of us loved coming back after long day of walking to relax in comfort and peace.

Om vÀrden

Michael Tubridy Àr vÀrd

VĂ€rdens profilbild
Retired contractor I built the home and live near by in Rockaway Beach
I grew up in the neighborhood

Varför vÀrden valde detta boende

Ideal location to visit the city and return home to Broad Channel a beautiful and tranquil setting on the water.

Vad som gör detta boende unikt

Fishing and swimming from dock alone with beautiful sunsets over Manhattan

SprÄk:

Engelska
Har du nÄgra förslag pÄ hur vi kan förbÀttra sidan?Ge feedback