About the property
- Half Baths0
- Minimum Stay4 - 14 nights
House, 3 bedroom, 3 baths, sleeps up to 6 people.
'Plum Crazy' is an open concept beach front home located directly on the crystal clear waters of protected Coco Bay. Watch the turtles, rays, bonefish, dolphins and beautiful sunsets from the covered 10' wrap around porches. Stargaze or sunbathe on the rooftop martini deck. Lounge on the beach in the shade of palms and casurinas just 12 steps from the house.
You may moor your boat directly in front of the house or leave it nearby on the newly constructed, free dock.
There are two bedrooms,(1queen, two singles) upstairs each with bathrooms and sea views. Downstairs is a private bedroom and bath with a queen bed and it's own entrance and patio. The gourmet kitchen is fully equipped with a gas range and dishwasher and was recently featured on a Caribbean Cooking Show. Our house also includes WiFi, , Direct TV, DVD and stereo. We are less than 5 minutes to the Green Turtle Club and Brendal's Dive Center. The clean sandy beach allows children to play right in front of the house while adults enjoy the spacious yard and porches.
To reach us fly into Treasure Cay and catch the 10 minute ferry to the Green Turtle Club where our caretaker will meet you.
Keywords: Beach Front, Ocean Front, Water Front, Beach house,cottage, Mooring, Dock, Bonefishing, snorkeling, diving, sandy beach.
- Response rate:
- Response time:
- within one day
- Calendar last updated:
- May 22, 2018
About Joseph Schnaufer
We are a couple who have a very long connection to the Cay and its inhabitants. We enjoy being out of doors, beachcombing, sailing, fishing, diving and sailing. We feel our location is ideal for all of these activities.
Joseph Schnaufer purchased this House in 2006
Why Joseph Schnaufer chose Green Turtle Cay
We chose to buy and build on Green Turtle Cay because the island is not overdeveloped and we feel that we are part of the community
What makes this House unique
We enjoy bird watching, sunsets, kayaking, sailing, beachcombing and just hanging out on the beach in front of our house. The bonefishing is great throughout Coco Bay. The town of New Plymouth is a short distance from Coco Bay and offers several restaurants, bars, a great library, a museum, several groceries and shopping.
Local Services & Businesses
Sports & Adventure Activities
100% refund if canceled at least 60 days before arrival date. 50% refund if canceled at least 30 days before arrival date. You must contact the owner directly to request cancellation.
Best Vacation Ever!
We stayed at Plum Crazy for ten days - late June/early July. The house was beautiful! It has a true island feel. Both bedrooms have an amazing view. The porch swing is so inviting and relaxing. Margaret, the caretaker, met us at the Green Turtle Club when we arrived and helped us transport our luggage to the house. We rented a golf cart and boat to get around the island. Everyone on Green Turtle was really friendly and helpful. We took the golf cart into town to get groceries and to restaurants for dinner. The Green Turtle Club and Bluff House were our favorites. Each day we took the boat to a different neighboring island and snorkeled for hours. The sea life was amazing - nurse sharks, sea turtles, star fish, rays, lemon sharks - very cool! Late in the afternoon, we returned each day to our quiet beach. The water is crystal clear and smooth as glass - great for floating around and relaxing. This vacation was wonderful for our whole family. Our three sons, ages 16, 14, and 9, loved every minute. My husband and I truly relaxed and felt away from the rigor of our normal life at home. You can't beat coffee or cocktails on the porch at Plum Crazy. Thanks for sharing it with us Joe!
Fantastic in every way !!
Wonderful property with incredible views in the most stunning ever location.
Exceeded all expectations for first time family visiting the Bahamas.
Great house right on the beach
Peaceful location with amazing views. Loved the house and deck.
Love Green Turtle!!
The house was amazing! It was a perfect spot for our honeymoon. Great sunset views. The beach is spectacular and even though green turtle was packed for the first week of lobster season we never saw another person on it. The property is very close to the ocean beach, green turtle cay club and brendals dive shop. Marg the caretaker was incredible and very helpful with everything we needed during our stay. We will be back. thank you
Thanks to Plum Crazy
We stayed next door to Plum Crazy, but the owner of PC was so helpful to us, I just wanted to give him and his wonderful house a shout out. Best spot on the bay and the house is fantastic. The calm waters of Coco Bay made it simple to keep our boat tied up and a short run to catch all the lobster and fish you could ever want. Thanks to the great advice of the owner, we got in touch with his friend, Marcus Jones, who put us right on the best spots with no hassle and no drama. Thanks again to the great people at Plum Crazy!
It has been almost a year since my husband and I visited there, but I can remember every minute of it, and I want to go back there again. We woke up every morning, had coffee on the deck, and then went paddle boarding for a couple of hours. Just need to paddle a short distance until you are seeing starfish and sea turtles and even a nurse shark! We have been to some of the other outer islands and have stayed in vrbos every time. This house and island is our favorite. We will be back. Thank you for sharing you house with us.
Bonefishing right out front!
Rates & Availability
Additional information about rental rates
These rates are for 2 bed 2 bath, 4 people. To add the beach bedroom and bath ( 2 people) add $120.00 per night. Full refund of deposit if we are able to re rent upon cancellation. The Holiday rate posted is for up to 4 people. For 5 or 6 please add $130 per night